Brazil's top court chief strips Justice de Moraes from 'fake news' inquiry he wielded against conservatives

 September 10, 2026

Brazil's Supreme Court president removed Justice Alexandre de Moraes from the controversial "fake news" inquiry on Wednesday, but upheld every ruling the justice issued under its sweeping authority.

Chief Justice Edson Fachin, who leads Brazil's Supreme Federal Tribunal, announced that de Moraes would no longer serve as rapporteur of the inquiry that has shaped Brazilian political life since 2019. The decision came amid an escalating internal conflict between de Moraes and a fellow justice, a banking fraud scandal that has exposed alleged private communications between de Moraes and a jailed financier, and growing pressure from within the court itself to restore some measure of institutional order. Breitbart News reported that Fachin also called for an upcoming plenary session of the full court to address the judiciary crisis.

Fachin's move strips de Moraes of the legal instrument he used for years to pursue political opponents, most prominently former President Jair Bolsonaro, but it does not undo a single order he signed. Every ruling, every ban, every censorship decision issued under the inquiry's framework remains in force.

Seven years of unchecked judicial power, and not one ruling reversed

The "fake news" inquiry launched in 2019 under then-Chief Justice José Antonio Dias Toffoli, who appointed de Moraes as its rapporteur. Brazil's state-owned news agency, Agência Brasil, described the inquiry's stated purpose as fighting the "dissemination of news that undermined the integrity and security" of the court, its justices, and their relatives.

In practice, the inquiry became something far broader. De Moraes used it to target conservative voices, order social media censorship, and pursue criminal investigations with minimal oversight. Bolsonaro became the inquiry's most prominent target, facing a cascade of legal actions that culminated in a 27-year prison sentence on alleged "crimes against democracy." The former president now serves that sentence under strict house arrest at his home in Brasília, legally barred from speaking to the press or receiving visitors other than doctors and lawyers.

One set of charges against Bolsonaro, accusations that he falsified a coronavirus vaccine card to visit the United States between late 2022 and early 2023, was dropped entirely in 2025. But the broader conviction stands, and de Moraes' removal from the inquiry does nothing to alter it.

A 2024 investigation by Folha de Sao Paulo, a left-leaning Brazilian newspaper, added another layer of concern. The report claimed de Moraes had allegedly ordered Brazil's Electoral Court to produce unofficial reports that he could then use to substantiate rulings against conservatives under the inquiry. That allegation, if accurate, would mean the justice was manufacturing his own evidentiary basis for the orders he signed. The allegation has not been formally confirmed or denied by the court.

When courts wield broad authority with limited accountability, the consequences tend to fall hardest on ordinary citizens and political outsiders. Procedural defects in high-profile cases are not unique to Brazil, they raise questions wherever judicial power operates without sufficient checks.

Unsealed messages between de Moraes and a jailed banker triggered the crisis

The chain of events that led to Fachin's decision began when Justice André Mendonça, who oversees the Banco Master financial fraud case, unsealed a police report. That report contained an analysis of alleged WhatsApp messages between de Moraes and Daniel Vorcaro, a São Paulo-based banker currently in police custody on corruption accusations tied to the Banco Master scandal.

The content of those messages has not been publicly detailed. But their mere existence, private communications between a sitting supreme court justice and a man under criminal investigation, set off an internal conflict that quickly consumed the court.

Days after the report surfaced, de Moraes accused Mendonça of "abuse of authority" in his handling of the Banco Master case. De Moraes then formally asked Fachin to use the "fake news" inquiry itself, the very tool now under scrutiny, to investigate his fellow justice. Fachin refused. Instead, he forwarded de Moraes' complaint against Mendonça directly to his own desk, declining to let the inquiry serve as a weapon in an internal dispute.

That refusal effectively ended de Moraes' control of the inquiry. Fachin announced the removal, upheld all prior rulings, and signaled his intention to bring the inquiry to a formal close.

De Moraes canceled a planned public defense, then went silent

The day after Fachin's announcement, de Moraes summoned reporters for a Thursday morning press statement. CNN Brasil reported, citing unnamed sources close to the justice, that de Moraes intended to "defend his actions in the fight against hate speech and the spread of fake news."

One hour before the event, de Moraes canceled it. He offered no explanation beyond saying it would be "rescheduled" at a later date. No new date has been announced.

Unnamed judges told CNN Brasil they believed the statement would have had the "unintended consequence" of "once again bringing institutional instability to the forefront of public opinion." In other words, de Moraes' own colleagues worried that letting him speak publicly would make the court's crisis worse.

CNN Brasil also reported that de Moraes has told allies he is not considering early retirement from the court, despite the controversy surrounding his alleged contact with Vorcaro. That claim came from unnamed sources attributed to de Moraes himself, not from any official court statement.

Questions about the proper scope of judicial authority are not confined to Brazil. In the United States, debates over how far courts can go in shaping executive policy continue to define the relationship between branches of government.

Toffoli's own controversy adds to the picture of a court in disorder

De Moraes is not the only justice whose conduct has drawn scrutiny. Toffoli, the former chief justice who originally appointed de Moraes to lead the inquiry in 2019, found himself at the center of a separate controversy earlier in September. Toffoli banned the presidential campaign of Renan Santos, an outsider right-wing candidate, then rapidly reversed the decision and allowed it to proceed. No detailed explanation for either action has been reported.

The pattern is consistent. Individual justices on Brazil's highest court have repeatedly exercised sweeping, unilateral power, banning candidates, censoring media, jailing political figures, and launching investigations, with little institutional pushback until the consequences become impossible to ignore.

Fachin's plenary session, whenever it convenes, will be the court's first formal attempt to address the crisis collectively. But the central question remains unanswered: who replaces de Moraes as rapporteur, and what happens to the inquiry itself? Fachin has said he intends to end it. Whether the full court agrees, and whether the rulings it produced will ever face independent review, is an open question.

Bolsonaro remains silenced while the court that convicted him fractures

Meanwhile, the man most affected by the inquiry's seven-year run sits under house arrest in Brasília, forbidden from speaking publicly. Bolsonaro's 27-year sentence stands. His communications are restricted to doctors and lawyers. The legal architecture de Moraes built to pursue him remains intact, upheld explicitly by Fachin even as he removed its architect.

The "fake news" inquiry was supposed to protect the court's integrity. Instead, it became a vehicle for one justice to accumulate extraordinary power, target political opponents, and, if the unsealed police report is any indication, maintain private contact with a man under criminal investigation for financial fraud. When the tool finally threatened a fellow justice, the court moved to shut it down. Not before.

Accountability that arrives only when the powerful turn on each other is not accountability at all, it is self-preservation dressed up as reform.


About Owen Bates

Breaking News:

Check This Out:

Heritage Review is a conservative email-newspaper that publishes every morning. Enter your best email to see our next edition: