A Massachusetts defense attorney is asking a judge to spare Lindsay Clancy a second trial by ruling from the bench that she was not criminally responsible for strangling her three young children, a legal move experts call a near-impossible long shot.
Kevin Reddington, who represents the 36-year-old former labor and delivery nurse, filed a motion asking Judge William Sullivan to set aside the hung-jury outcome and acquit Clancy outright. The filing came days after Sullivan declared a mistrial when jurors deadlocked on three counts of first-degree murder. Eleven of the twelve jurors were ready to clear Clancy of criminal responsibility. One holdout prevented a unanimous verdict.
Reddington's motion argues that prosecutors failed to meet their burden of proof on the central question: whether Clancy understood that what she was doing was wrong. Under Massachusetts law, prosecutors had to prove either that Clancy did not have a mental disease or defect, or that despite having one, she retained the substantial capacity to appreciate the wrongfulness of her actions or to conform her conduct to the law.
Neither side's psychiatric experts disputed that Clancy suffered from a severe mental illness. Reddington's filing put it bluntly, as reported by the Associated Press:
"The testimony bears on which illness she had, not on whether she had one."
That framing is central to the defense strategy. If every expert who took the stand, prosecution witnesses included, agreed Clancy was mentally ill, Reddington argues, then prosecutors never cleared the first legal hurdle. And if they could not prove the absence of mental disease, the second question, whether Clancy retained the capacity to know her actions were wrong, becomes the entire case. Reddington says prosecutors failed there, too.
The jury of nine women and three men deliberated for 38 hours over seven days before the deadlock became irreversible. During deliberations, Reddington asked Judge Sullivan to dismiss the holdout juror, claiming that juror refused to follow the court's instructions. Sullivan declined, telling the courtroom he did not feel it was proper to side with one party over the other.
"I don't feel it is proper for me to side with one side or the other of the deliberations. I don't feel it's appropriate for me to say, I agree with one juror or the 11."
Sullivan acknowledged the trial had been emotionally and physically exhausting for everyone involved. He ultimately declared the mistrial.
At least one juror has since spoken publicly, admitting she changed her vote after feeling pressure from what she described as "big personalities" in the deliberation room, a detail that raises its own questions about the integrity of the process on both sides of the split.
The prosecution's theory rested not on disputing Clancy's mental illness but on arguing she retained enough awareness to be held criminally responsible. Prosecutors pointed to her functional behavior in the weeks, days, and hours before the 2023 killings: she drove, planned a birthday party for one of her children, and attended a doctor's appointment. In their telling, a woman who could manage those tasks could also appreciate the wrongfulness of strangling three children.
Reddington's filing directly challenged that reasoning:
"Competence at routine tasks, during a crisis which every witness agreed was acute, is not proof of criminal responsibility beyond a reasonable doubt."
Neither side disputed the underlying facts of what happened. Clancy strangled her three children, five-year-old Cora, three-year-old Dawson, and eight-month-old Callan, in the family's home in 2023. She then jumped from the second story of the house. She survived but has been paralyzed from the waist down ever since. She remains in a psychiatric hospital, where she is expected to stay until her case is resolved.
The trial itself was wrenching. The children's father, whose name was not released in court filings, placed the 911 call after discovering the children's bodies. That call was played for jurors. When autopsy photos of the three children were shown in court, Clancy sobbed audibly, prompting Judge Sullivan to call a short break.
Reddington's motion, technically a 25(b)(2) motion under Massachusetts procedure, asks Sullivan to do something judges almost never do: overrule a jury's failure to reach a verdict and impose an acquittal from the bench. The motion is scheduled for a court conference on September 29.
Boston defense lawyer Peter Elikann told the New York Post that the granting of such a motion is "rare in the extreme." He could recall only one successful instance in Massachusetts, the 1997 Louise Woodward case, in which a British au pair was convicted of second-degree murder in the death of an infant, and the judge reduced the conviction to involuntary manslaughter and sentenced her to time served.
"Most judges go through their entire career without even granting one of those once."
If Sullivan denies the motion, Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz will face a decision: retry the case, pursue reduced charges, negotiate a plea deal, or drop the matter entirely. Cruz did not respond to a phone message seeking comment on his office's plans. The silence from the DA's office leaves the case in limbo, and leaves three dead children without a legal resolution.
Reddington, for his part, has not been quiet. In a separate interview, he outlined a multi-pronged strategy that includes arguing a retrial would violate double jeopardy protections, since the mistrial was declared over the defense's objection, and pushing for charges to be reduced to second-degree murder if a new trial goes forward. He also called for a bench trial rather than a second jury trial. Fox News reported that Reddington went so far as to call on President Trump to personally contact DA Cruz to discourage a retrial.
Reddington also made a rare concession about his own conduct, admitting he had no right to accuse the holdout juror of not knowing the names of the three dead children. "I had no right to accuse the man of not knowing the names of those kids and I regret that," he said.
The Clancy case has created intense public interest from the start. President Trump himself weighed in after the mistrial, saying "there'll be a price" for killing three children, a statement that reflected the frustration many Americans feel when the legal system produces no clear answer in a case involving the deaths of the most vulnerable victims imaginable.
The defense framing, postpartum psychosis so severe it erased criminal responsibility, is not new. A Bronx judge recently ruled a mother not criminally responsible for the stabbing deaths of two young children, citing the same diagnosis. These cases force the justice system to weigh genuine mental illness against the public's expectation that someone answer for the death of a child.
But the question in Massachusetts is narrower than the moral debate. It is whether one judge should do what twelve jurors could not: deliver a final verdict. Sullivan has the legal authority. Whether he has the appetite to use it, in a case this public, this raw, and this politically charged, is another matter entirely.
The Washington Examiner noted that Reddington's filing rests heavily on the fact that both sides' expert witnesses agreed Clancy suffered from severe mental illness, a point the defense treats as dispositive and the prosecution apparently could not overcome even with evidence of Clancy's day-to-day functioning.
For now, Clancy sits in a psychiatric hospital, paralyzed and awaiting a September 29 hearing. DA Cruz sits in silence. And three children, Cora, Dawson, and Callan, sit in graves, their deaths unresolved by a system that spent weeks in trial and still could not reach a conclusion.
Whatever diagnosis explains what Lindsay Clancy did, five-year-old Cora, three-year-old Dawson, and eight-month-old Callan deserved someone in that courtroom who spoke for them, and so far, the system has not delivered.