The Trump administration's Department of Justice has now won court rulings against six states that offered in-state college tuition to illegal immigrants, and filed lawsuits against 15 more states that still do.
Kansas became the latest state forced to end its in-state tuition policy for illegal immigrants after the DOJ prevailed in court, adding to earlier wins in Texas, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Nebraska, and Illinois. The legal campaign, which the Justice Department says rests on a federal law passed more than three decades ago, has expanded rapidly, with 21 states now facing federal complaints over policies the administration says put illegal immigrants ahead of American citizens.
Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward Jr. framed the effort in blunt terms when the DOJ announced its latest round of lawsuits in August:
"Over 30 years ago, Congress made clear that States cannot put illegal aliens before our Nation's own citizens. By granting illegal aliens in-state tuition, Washington, Oregon, New Mexico, and Arizona are pushing citizens to the side and ignoring federal law. No more. As of today, we have now sued 21 states who we allege were thwarting Congress's clear prohibition on placing aliens over citizens. Our efforts will not cease until President Trump's promise is fulfilled: illegal aliens will not receive benefits denied to American citizens."
The federal law at the center of these cases bars states from making illegal immigrants eligible for college benefits based on residency unless all U.S. citizens, regardless of which state they live in, qualify for the same deal. In practice, that means a state cannot charge an illegal immigrant the lower in-state rate while charging an out-of-state American student the full price.
The DOJ's six courtroom victories have forced Kansas, Texas, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Nebraska, and Illinois to scrap their in-state tuition policies for illegal immigrants. A federal judge struck down Illinois's law as part of that string of wins, removing one of the most prominent blue-state tuition programs from the books.
Minnesota is the lone state where the DOJ lost. The Justice Department is appealing that ruling to the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals, though the specific reasoning behind the Minnesota court's decision has not been publicly detailed in the DOJ's statements.
The legal momentum may be shifting further in the administration's favor. The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, which covers Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi, recently upheld a ruling prohibiting states from offering in-state tuition to illegal immigrants, strengthening the DOJ's position heading into the remaining cases.
Beyond the six states where the DOJ has already won, lawsuits remain active or pending against a wide swath of the country. The states still facing litigation include Minnesota, Virginia, California, New Jersey, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Maryland, Colorado, New York, Connecticut, Vermont, Arizona, New Mexico, Oregon, and Washington.
The most recent batch of complaints targeted Arizona, New Mexico, Oregon, and Washington. In Washington state alone, illegal immigrants could receive a tuition discount worth $31,054 under state law, a benefit unavailable to an American citizen living one state away, Fox News reported.
That $31,054 figure puts the stakes in concrete terms. A family in Idaho paying full out-of-state rates at the University of Washington would subsidize a discount handed to someone in the country illegally. The DOJ argues that arrangement violates the plain text of federal law.
The Justice Department also filed suits against New York, Connecticut, and Vermont, challenging not just in-state tuition rates but also state policies providing financial aid and scholarships to illegal immigrants. The Washington Examiner reported that those complaints seek to block state laws, regulations, and policies allowing illegal immigrants to receive taxpayer-funded higher education benefits.
Assistant Attorney General Brett A. Shumate, who leads the Justice Department's Civil Division, offered a sharper summary of the administration's legal theory:
"This is a simple matter of federal law: colleges cannot provide benefits to illegal aliens that they do not provide to U.S. citizens. This Department of Justice will not tolerate American students being treated like second-class citizens in their own country."
The argument is straightforward. Congress wrote a law. More than twenty states ignored it, or interpreted it in ways that let them keep handing out tuition breaks to people who entered the country illegally. The DOJ says the plain reading of the statute leaves no room for that.
Whether every court agrees remains to be seen. Minnesota's ruling shows the legal path is not guaranteed, and the 8th Circuit appeal will test whether the DOJ's winning streak holds outside friendlier jurisdictions. But six consecutive wins, including in Illinois, a deep-blue state, suggest the federal law is doing what the administration says it does.
The broader political context matters, too. The DNC recently voted on a resolution to abolish ICE and end immigration detention, a move that underscores how far apart the two parties stand on enforcement. While Democrats push to dismantle immigration agencies, the Trump DOJ is using existing federal law to claw back benefits that states extended without Congressional authorization.
For more than three decades, the federal prohibition sat on the books while state after state passed laws offering in-state tuition to illegal immigrants. Some states did so openly, arguing that educating all residents, regardless of immigration status, served the public interest. Others structured their programs to avoid the appearance of a direct conflict with federal law, tying eligibility to high school attendance rather than immigration status.
The Trump DOJ has taken the position that those workarounds do not survive scrutiny. The 5th Circuit's recent ruling backs that view, holding that the federal prohibition means what it says: states cannot offer residency-based college benefits to illegal immigrants unless every American citizen qualifies for the same benefit, no matter where they live.
The administration's approach has drawn fierce resistance from Democratic officials who accuse the White House of weaponizing the Justice Department. That charge has become a familiar refrain, California Governor Gavin Newsom has alleged that Trump directed DOJ investigations into him personally. But the tuition cases rest on a statute Congress passed decades ago, not on executive orders or novel legal theories.
The DOJ has also shown it will not back down from judicial pushback. In other contexts, the Trump Justice Department has refused court demands it considered overreach, signaling a willingness to fight on multiple legal fronts simultaneously.
Several key details remain unclear. The DOJ has not publicly identified the specific statute by name in its press statements, referring only to a Congressional prohibition passed "over 30 years ago." The specific court rulings in each of the six won cases, including the judges, docket numbers, and legal reasoning, have not been detailed in the department's public announcements.
The Minnesota loss raises its own questions. What legal reasoning did the court use to rule against the DOJ? Did the judge find the federal statute ambiguous, or did the ruling turn on procedural grounds? The 8th Circuit appeal will likely answer those questions, and the outcome could shape how the remaining 14 active cases proceed.
There is also the matter of who benefits from these tuition policies. The DOJ's statements reference "illegal aliens and their non-resident children," but whether those children include U.S.-born citizens, who would hold citizenship by birthright, is not addressed in the department's public filings.
What is clear is the scale. Twenty-one states sued. Six forced to comply. One loss under appeal. And a federal appellate court already siding with the administration's reading of the law.
For thirty years, states handed out tuition breaks that federal law prohibited, and nobody in Washington made them stop. Now someone has, and the states that built policies on the assumption that the law would never be enforced are finding out what happens when it is.