A surrogate mother who fled to Texas rather than abort a baby diagnosed with a serious heart defect has filed an emergency appeal with the U.S. Supreme Court, arguing the biological parents plan to put the infant in hospice instead of pursuing life-saving care.
McKenna West carried the child for Omar Ahmed and Nausheen Gilkar, a California couple who contracted her as a surrogate. During a 20-week medical checkup in Alaska, doctors discovered the baby had hypoplastic left heart syndrome, a condition that prevents normal blood flow through the heart and can cause death within days or weeks without treatment. Ahmed and Gilkar asked West to undergo an abortion at 23 weeks of pregnancy. She refused.
West then traveled to Texas, where the baby, whom she calls "Gabriel" and the biological parents call "Rumi", was born on August 12. The infant underwent emergency heart surgery shortly after birth. He is now roughly four weeks old and, according to NewsNation reporting, remains in critical condition with potential complications, according to the couple's attorney.
West chose Texas deliberately. The state's restrictive abortion laws meant the procedure Ahmed and Gilkar sought could not easily be carried out there. But the legal landscape that shielded the child before birth has not shielded West's claim to him after delivery.
A California court issued an order recognizing Ahmed and Gilkar as the child's legal parents. On September 2, a Texas court granted full credit to that California judgment, effectively dismissing West from the Texas proceedings with prejudice. Ahmed and Gilkar also obtained a restraining order barring West from seeing or holding the baby.
West had sought conservatorship of the infant in Texas and lost. Her emergency appeal to the Supreme Court is her last available move. In the filing, her attorneys argued that the California judgment was unlawful and that its consequences are severe.
West's lawyers framed the stakes bluntly in the Supreme Court filing, as AP News reported:
"The stakes of the decisions below are enormous. But because of the unlawful California judgment, she has been dismissed with prejudice from the Texas proceedings and denied any information about or control over the medically fragile child."
The Supreme Court has not indicated whether it will hear the case. The justices have faced a growing number of emergency appeals across a range of politically charged disputes in recent terms, and this one lands squarely at the intersection of surrogacy law, parental rights, and the right to life.
At the core of West's argument is a claim about what Ahmed and Gilkar intend to do next. She stated that she does not believe the couple will provide life-saving care and that they plan to place the baby in hospice rather than authorize additional surgeries. Babies born with hypoplastic left heart syndrome often require multiple operations and, in some cases, a heart transplant. Lifelong complications are common, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Ahmed and Gilkar dispute West's account. They say West knew from the surrogacy contract that they would terminate the pregnancy in the event of a fetal abnormality. They say she violated the contract by refusing the abortion and fleeing the state.
Nausheen Gilkar, wiping away tears during an August 25 court hearing in Dallas, offered a two-word rebuttal, as the New York Post reported:
"He's our child."
The couple's attorney stated the child is in critical condition and appears to have potential complications following surgery. Beyond that, the current treatment plan has not been publicly disclosed.
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton inserted himself into the dispute early. He vowed to do anything to protect the child as West remained in the state. A Texas judge initially ordered the baby to stay in Texas and receive medical care until a custody hearing could be held.
But the September 2 ruling granting full credit to the California judgment changed the legal picture. The restraining order placed medical decision-making authority with Ahmed and Gilkar, not with West and not with the state of Texas, while still requiring that life-saving care be provided. That distinction matters. West now has no legal standing in Texas proceedings and no right to contact the baby.
Just The News reported Paxton's earlier statement on the case directly:
"Baby Gabriel deserves a chance at life, and I will not allow anyone to unlawfully deny him medically necessary care."
Whether Paxton's office has taken concrete legal action beyond that public statement remains unclear from available court records. The case has drawn attention to the broader question of how far a state attorney general's authority extends when a court in another state has already established legal parentage.
The dispute exposes a gap in American law that most people never think about until a case like this forces it into view. No federal statute governs surrogacy. Each state sets its own rules. California, which has one of the most permissive surrogacy frameworks in the country, recognized Ahmed and Gilkar as the legal parents. Texas, which has some of the most restrictive abortion laws in the nation, initially shielded the pregnancy from termination but ultimately deferred to the California court's custody determination.
The result is a jurisdictional tangle. West entered the surrogacy agreement under one legal regime, fled to another state to avoid what she considered a morally unacceptable outcome, and now finds herself stripped of any legal relationship to the child she carried and delivered. The Supreme Court has increasingly been asked to resolve conflicts between competing state legal frameworks, and this case presents one of the sharpest versions of that problem.
Breitbart reported that the surrogacy contract contained what it described as an "abortion on demand" clause, and that the biological parents had threatened to sue West for $250,000 after she refused to comply. West rejected the couple's offer to simply walk away. She offered instead to take full responsibility for the child. Ahmed and Gilkar turned her down.
West stated her position publicly earlier in the dispute:
"Every life matters. No woman should be forced to end the life of the baby she is carrying, including me... Baby Gabriel should receive a chance at life."
The case has drawn legislative attention as well, raising questions about whether surrogacy contracts that include clauses compelling a woman to undergo an abortion are enforceable, or whether they violate public policy in states that restrict or ban the procedure. Those questions remain unanswered. No court has yet ruled on the enforceability of the specific contract clause at issue.
While the legal arguments move through the system, a four-week-old baby remains in a Texas hospital in critical condition. He has already undergone at least one surgery. He may need more. He may need a heart transplant. The woman who carried him for nine months and delivered him cannot hold him or receive updates on his condition.
The couple who hired her as a surrogate, and who asked her to end the pregnancy when the diagnosis came, are now his legal parents with full decision-making authority. Whether they will authorize the additional surgeries the child may require is the question West wants the Supreme Court to answer before it is too late.
The Washington Examiner noted the baby underwent emergency heart surgery days after birth, underscoring the life-or-death medical reality behind the legal filings. The child's condition remains serious enough that delay itself carries risk.
The Supreme Court has been flooded with emergency appeals in recent years, and not every petition receives a hearing. But few cases arrive with stakes this concrete: a critically ill infant, a surrogate barred from his bedside, and biological parents whose stated intentions remain disputed.
State attorneys general like Paxton have shown a willingness to take fights to the highest court when they believe a competing state's legal order threatens their own citizens or principles. Whether the justices see this case the same way will determine what happens to one small boy in a Texas hospital bed.
When a surrogacy contract includes a clause that can compel a woman to end a life, and no federal law exists to draw the line, the only question left is whether anyone with the authority to act will do so before the window closes.