Sacramento County sheriff's deputies had the legal authority to arrest the illegal immigrant who killed a 38-year-old California waitress outside a Panera Bread, but say they couldn't locate him despite multiple attempts, a failure that left a grieving mother asking why no one protected her daughter.
Shalini Thakur reported to the Sacramento County Sheriff's Office that 22-year-old Rohit Rohit had violated a restraining order she obtained against him on May 29. Deputies and detectives made at least two attempts to find him afterward. They searched places he was known to frequent. They never made contact. On a Tuesday shortly after, Rohit killed Thakur outside a Panera Bread restaurant in Sacramento.
Lt. Amar Gandhi, a spokesperson for the Sacramento County Sheriff's Office, told reporters that an arrest would have followed if deputies had found Rohit:
"If we made contact with him, yeah, I am certain there would have been an arrest. But again, there was no contact made."
But no large-scale manhunt was ever launched. Gandhi said the alleged restraining order violation was classified as a lower-level misdemeanor, and the Sheriff's Office did not treat the case as domestic violence because the pair had not been involved romantically. Thakur herself had described the relationship as "being friends," Gandhi said.
That classification meant Rohit's case sat in a stack alongside countless others. Gandhi acknowledged the grim arithmetic plainly.
"There's not going to be a massive, large-scale manhunt for this person. But there is follow-up. There is stuff done."
Rohit's behavior toward Thakur grew steadily more menacing throughout the year, according to the Sheriff's Office and court documents. He first met Thakur while delivering DoorDash orders from the IHOP where she worked as a waitress in 2025. What followed was a pattern of conduct that went far beyond unwanted attention.
He threatened to kill Thakur and himself on multiple occasions. He placed an Apple AirTag tracking device on her car. He made a copy of her house key without permission. He showed up at her workplace daily. He slashed her tires and then followed her, offering to change them when she pulled over on the side of the road.
Thakur obtained the restraining order on May 29. On July 29, she reported that Rohit had violated it by ordering or delivering groceries to her, a contact she believed broke the court's terms. That report triggered the deputies' attempts to locate him. They failed.
The gap between what Thakur reported and how the system responded is difficult to square. A man who had threatened to kill a woman multiple times, tracked her movements with hidden technology, copied her house key, and appeared at her job every day was treated as a routine misdemeanor case. The restraining order violation did not elevate the threat level in the eyes of the Sheriff's Office because the relationship was not classified as romantic.
That distinction may have followed the letter of California law. It did not protect Shalini Thakur.
Rohit Rohit was not supposed to be in the United States at all. The Department of Homeland Security arrested him in August 2023 after he crossed into the country illegally at the Arizona border. He was an Indian national with no legal right to remain.
Approximately one month later, during the Biden administration, DHS released him on an "order of recognizance", a document that essentially let him walk free into the interior of the country. DHS itself later confirmed that Rohit remained in the country illegally. A DHS spokesperson said the killing "would have been completely avoided" if the Biden administration had not released Rohit.
The catch-and-release decision in 2023 set the chain of events in motion. Rohit was free to settle in Sacramento, pick up DoorDash deliveries, meet Thakur at her workplace, and begin the months-long campaign of stalking and threats that ended with her death outside a fast-food restaurant.
This case is not an isolated failure. A Newsom-appointed judge freed an illegal immigrant one day before he allegedly stabbed a California retiree to death, another instance where the system released a dangerous individual and a citizen paid the price.
California's sanctuary state laws limited the Sacramento County Sheriff's Office's ability to cooperate with federal immigration authorities on Rohit's case. The state's legal framework restricts local law enforcement from honoring federal immigration detainers or sharing information with agencies like ICE in many circumstances, policies that effectively wall off local cops from the federal enforcement apparatus.
So even as deputies searched for a man who had threatened to kill a woman, who was in the country illegally, and who had already been arrested and released by DHS, the system's own rules made it harder to bring every available tool to bear.
Gandhi pushed back against the suggestion that nothing was done. He said detectives follow up on restraining order violation cases daily and carry heavy caseloads.
"It's just the sad truth of it all. These cases, they come in every day. These detectives do have stacks of these cases, and they do follow up on these cases literally every day."
He added: "To say that nothing was done is absolutely incorrect."
The pattern of released illegal immigrants committing violent crimes extends well beyond California. A Salvadoran illegal immigrant was charged with murder after a Virginia mother was found stabbed near a trail outside Washington, D.C., another case where a previously encountered individual went on to commit a fatal act of violence.
Shalini Thakur's mother, Sudesh Kumari, spoke to reporters after her daughter's death. Her words carried the weight of someone who watched the system fail at every turn.
"I am alone in this world. Restraining order after restraining order... police did not protect my daughter."
Kumari told Fox News that her daughter had reported the stalking to police multiple times. "She could have been saved," Kumari said. "She told police so many times. She called them, but nobody did anything."
She also described her daughter simply: "She loved them all. She loved everyone."
Sacramento Sheriff Jim Cooper said after the killing that a quick law enforcement response prevented Rohit from causing additional harm. Cooper stated he believed Rohit "was headed somewhere else to do someone else harm." Rohit is also dead, though the circumstances of his death were not detailed by the Sheriff's Office.
Tragic cases involving illegal immigrants who were previously in government custody continue to surface across the country. In New Jersey, a nine-month-old was killed in a parking lot after an illegal immigrant allegedly drove without a license, yet another life lost after the system failed to act.
The timeline of this case reads like a catalog of missed opportunities. DHS had Rohit in custody in August 2023 and let him go. Thakur obtained a restraining order. She reported a violation. Deputies looked for Rohit twice and could not find him. No manhunt followed. The case was classified as a misdemeanor. Sanctuary laws blocked local-federal cooperation. And Rohit walked free long enough to kill the woman who had begged the system for help.
Several open questions remain. No specific details about how Thakur was killed have been released by the Sheriff's Office, though one source reference describes a "gunman." It is unclear whether prosecutors or a judge took any action between the restraining order violation report and the killing. The conditions attached to Rohit's "order of recognizance", and whether anyone monitored his compliance, have not been disclosed.
In a separate but thematically similar case, an illegal immigrant was charged in a New York Harbor capsizing that killed a mother and her infant daughter, another preventable death tied to an individual the system had the power to remove but did not.
Gandhi called the justice system "imperfect." That word does a lot of heavy lifting when a woman who filed restraining orders, reported violations, and called police repeatedly ends up dead outside a sandwich shop while her stalker roamed free on a federal release order.
Shalini Thakur did everything the system told her to do. She got the restraining order. She called the police. She reported the violation. The system told her it was handling things. It wasn't.