Roy Cooper says critics wanted even more prisoners freed — as his Senate bid faces scrutiny over 4,200 early releases

 September 13, 2026

Democrat Roy Cooper, now running for a North Carolina Senate seat, told CNN that plaintiffs in a COVID-era prison release settlement were "very frustrated" his administration didn't let even more convicted criminals out, a claim his Republican opponent calls a stunning admission.

Cooper sat for an interview with CNN's Manu Raju on September 13, 2026, and faced a direct question about the settlement deal that has become the centerpiece of Republican attacks against his candidacy. Raju noted that roughly 3,500 prisoners were released early under the agreement and asked Cooper whether he had any regrets about how his administration handled it.

Cooper did not express regret. Instead, he framed the releases as mandatory and then went further, suggesting the real complaint came from the other direction, that advocacy groups wanted the state to open the doors wider.

In Cooper's words to Raju:

"This is something that the state had to do, because the court ordered it. And, I think a lot of people believe, if you ask the plaintiffs, they were very frustrated that more weren't released."

That framing puts Cooper in a peculiar position for a candidate trying to win a general election in a competitive state. He is not merely defending the early releases, he is positioning himself between voters alarmed by the policy and activist plaintiffs who, by his own account, wanted it to go further. For a candidate whose record on releasing convicted criminals is already under sustained fire, the remark hands his opponent fresh material.

A settlement that grew from 3,500 to 4,200, and the public wasn't told the full story

The prison release settlement dates to 2021, when Cooper's administration and groups described in court filings as civil rights organizations reached an agreement requiring North Carolina to free a minimum of 3,500 convicted criminals from state prison. At the time, prison officials told a state legislative committee that only convicts whose sentences were ending in 2021 would be released.

That assurance turned out to be misleading. Officials later corrected the record before the same legislative committee, acknowledging that violent offenders would also be freed under the deal. Breitbart News reported that the actual total climbed to 4,200, roughly 700 more than the settlement's stated minimum.

Republican Senate candidate Michael Whatley has made Cooper's crime record the center of his campaign. Whatley has argued the true number of released convicts could be even higher than 4,200, citing a June 2026 NRSC fact-check that flagged multiple problems with Cooper's own campaign advertising on the issue.

Cooper, for his part, accused Republicans of "lying about all of these cases that they're trying to connect to this." He also claimed to be "the one who has actually prosecuted violent criminals and put them behind bars", a reference to his earlier career as a prosecutor.

DeCarlos Brown and the murder that blew the case open

The list of specific offenders released under the settlement was initially shielded from public view. It only came to light after authorities confirmed that DeCarlos Brown, a man on the release list, had been accused of murdering Iryna Zarutska, a Ukrainian refugee, on Charlotte's light rail system.

That case gave the abstract policy debate a human face, and a victim. Zarutska, a refugee who had come to the United States seeking safety, was killed in a public transit system by a man the state had freed early. The revelation forced the release of the full offender list and raised questions Cooper has struggled to answer ever since.

When confronted about his record at a campaign appearance in August 2026, Cooper told reporters:

"Independent fact checks show most of what they're saying is simply not true. I'm the only one in this race who's actually prosecuted violent criminals and worked to keep them behind bars."

Prior reporting from Breitbart's Matt Mercer directly challenged that claim. Court and public records, Mercer wrote, confirm Cooper signed a legally binding agreement requiring North Carolina to release a minimum of 3,500 convicted criminals, making him, by that account, the only governor in the country who entered into such a binding commitment.

Cooper's deflection to Trump doesn't settle the question

Pressed by Raju, Cooper pivoted to a familiar target. He claimed President Trump "released 13,000 prisoners, at least, during this COVID-era" and "signed a bill to do that." Cooper described his own administration's actions as following "the lead of President Trump's team."

Cooper did not name the specific legislation he attributed to Trump, and the claim was not independently verified within the interview. The comparison, even if accurate on the numbers, sidesteps a critical distinction: Cooper's settlement was a binding legal agreement negotiated with outside advocacy groups, not a piece of federal legislation passed by Congress. The accountability structures are different, and Cooper was the executive who chose to settle rather than litigate.

Beyond the prison releases, Cooper's record on public safety includes vetoing legislation that would have required state cooperation with ICE detainers, vetoing bills that would have increased penalties for rioting, and vetoing measures that would have allowed more juvenile crimes to be handled within the justice system. Taken together, the pattern suggests a governor who consistently sided with leniency over enforcement when forced to choose.

Whatley's campaign sees an opening Cooper keeps widening

Whatley has not needed to manufacture attacks. Cooper's own public statements keep supplying them. First came the misleading assurances to the state legislature in 2021, corrected only after the fact. Then came the shielded offender list, pried open by a murder case. Then came the campaign-trail claim that fact-checkers had vindicated him, contradicted by the documentary record. And now, the CNN interview in which Cooper volunteered that the plaintiffs, the groups who pushed for mass releases, wished he had gone even further.

Each iteration follows the same arc: Cooper minimizes, deflects, and then inadvertently reveals a position further from the mainstream than the one he was trying to defend. A candidate running in a swing state typically moves toward the center on crime. Cooper, under pressure, keeps drifting toward the advocacy groups who wanted more convicts freed.

The political consequences remain to be seen. North Carolina's Senate race is competitive, and crime is a top-tier issue with voters who remember the accountability debates that have defined recent cycles. Cooper's argument that the releases were court-ordered may carry legal weight. But telling voters that activists wished he had freed even more prisoners is not a message designed to reassure the people who ride Charlotte's light rail, or any parent, business owner, or taxpayer who expects the justice system to keep convicted criminals behind bars until they have served their time.

Raju gave Cooper a clean chance to express regret. Cooper chose instead to express sympathy for the side that wanted more leniency. Voters in November will decide whether that answer was honest, or disqualifying.

When a politician's defense of a controversial policy amounts to "the people who sued us wish I'd done more of it," the defense has become the indictment.


About Jenny Curran

Breaking News:

Check This Out:

Heritage Review is a conservative email-newspaper that publishes every morning. Enter your best email to see our next edition: