Massachusetts court reprimands judge who helped illegal immigrant dodge ICE — and DHS says sanctuary judges are next

 September 14, 2026

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court has formally reprimanded a judge for helping an illegal immigrant slip out a courthouse back door to evade federal agents, and the Department of Homeland Security says every sanctuary judge in America should take note.

Judge Shelley Joseph received the rare public rebuke on September 10 after a years-long saga that began in an April 2018 courtroom, where prosecutors say she orchestrated the escape of a twice-deported illegal alien while ICE agents waited just outside to arrest him. DHS General Counsel James Percival told Breitbart News that the reprimand sends a clear message far beyond Massachusetts.

The state's highest court found that Joseph "created an appearance of impropriety in violation of her duties" by instructing her clerk to shut off the courtroom's audio recording system during a sidebar conversation, a move that effectively hid what happened next from the official record. What prosecutors allege happened next: Joseph allowed the defendant, Oscar Manuel Peguero, who had used the alias Jose Medina-Perez, to walk out of the courthouse through a rear exit, bypassing the ICE agents stationed at the front.

Twice deported, still in a Massachusetts courtroom

Peguero's history with the U.S. immigration system stretches back more than two decades. In January 2003, he flew into Boston and tried to enter the country by claiming to be an American citizen. He was arrested and deported.

Four years later, in April 2007, he crossed the southern border illegally through New Mexico. Border Patrol agents caught him. He was deported again in June 2007.

At some point after that second removal, Peguero crossed the border a third time. By April 2018, he was living in Massachusetts, where police arrested him on drug possession charges. He also had an outstanding warrant as a fugitive from justice in Pennsylvania.

ICE lodged a detainer against Peguero on the day of his arrest, a formal request that local authorities hold him so federal agents could take custody. The detainer was not honored. Instead, ICE agents went to the courthouse themselves, prepared to arrest Peguero when he appeared before a judge.

That judge was Shelley Joseph. And prosecutors say she made sure the agents left empty-handed.

Joseph instructed her clerk to kill the courtroom recording

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court's reprimand centered on one specific act: Joseph's instruction to her clerk to turn off the courtroom audio recording system during a sidebar discussion about Peguero's case. The court found that this conduct, combined with her proposal to detain Peguero overnight in state custody rather than release him to federal agents, crossed a line.

Prosecutors went further. In 2019, they charged Joseph with three counts: conspiracy to obstruct justice, aiding and abetting obstruction of justice, and aiding and abetting obstruction of a federal proceeding. The charges painted a picture of a judge who actively colluded with a defense attorney and a court officer to let an illegal immigrant with multiple deportations and an outstanding warrant walk free rather than face federal immigration enforcement.

Joseph was suspended from the bench. The case dragged on for years. Then, in 2022, the Biden administration dropped all criminal charges after Joseph agreed to refer herself to the state's Commission on Judicial Conduct.

That referral led to the September 10 reprimand, the only formal consequence Joseph has faced for conduct that prosecutors once considered serious enough to warrant felony charges. Joseph's attorney, Elizabeth Mulvey, told AP News the outcome vindicated her client.

"We are grateful to the hearing officer who undertook this monumental task and pleased that his efforts have shown that this was a baseless federal prosecution from the beginning."

Mulvey also said it had been "an incredibly long and difficult eight years" for Joseph. The DHS general counsel offered a different reading of the situation entirely.

Percival: 'Sanctuary politicians and sanctuary judges alike are on notice'

James Percival did not treat the reprimand as a vindication. He treated it as a warning shot.

Percival told Breitbart News that Joseph's case reflects a pattern the department encounters across the country, judges who see their role not as upholding the law but as shielding illegal immigrants from federal enforcement.

"This judicial misconduct reflects what DHS is facing across the country. Certain judges think it is their duty to undermine, rather than enforce, federal immigration law."

He did not stop there. Percival stated plainly that the conduct Joseph was accused of carries criminal exposure, regardless of whether the Biden administration chose to pursue it.

"Helping illegal aliens escape from immigration officers is a felony. Sanctuary politicians and sanctuary judges alike are on notice."

The distinction between the Biden administration's handling of the Joseph case and the current DHS posture is sharp. Biden's Justice Department walked away from felony charges against a judge accused of obstructing federal immigration enforcement. Percival's statement signals that the current administration views such conduct as a live enforcement priority, and that judges who engage in it should expect consequences.

The Joseph case is not an isolated incident. In Wisconsin, a federal court recently upheld the obstruction conviction of Judge Hannah Dugan, who was found guilty of felony obstruction for similarly helping a man evade immigration authorities. The New York Post reported that Dugan was fined $5,000 but spared prison time.

A pattern of judges shielding illegal immigrants from federal law

Dugan's conviction and Joseph's reprimand land at a moment when the friction between local courts and federal immigration enforcement has become a recurring flashpoint. Judges in multiple jurisdictions have drawn scrutiny, and in some cases, formal legal consequences, for actions that critics say amount to obstruction of lawful deportation proceedings.

Members of Congress have responded to the broader trend. Rep. Andy Ogles has filed impeachment articles against a federal judge over a ruling that blocked the administration's immigration policy, reflecting growing frustration on Capitol Hill with what conservatives view as judicial overreach on immigration.

The Joseph case stands out because of how starkly the facts contrast with the outcome. A judge allegedly shut off the courtroom recording, helped a twice-deported illegal alien with a fugitive warrant dodge ICE agents, and faced three felony charges, only for those charges to be dropped and the final penalty reduced to a formal reprimand.

For Joseph, the saga is over. For the illegal immigrant she allegedly helped escape, the record is incomplete. Whether Peguero was ever apprehended by ICE after walking out of that courthouse back door remains unclear from the available record.

Federal courts have also weighed in on the legal framework surrounding these cases. The Fifth Circuit ruled that illegal immigrants have no constitutional right to remain free during deportation proceedings, a decision that reinforces the legal authority ICE agents were trying to exercise the day Joseph allegedly sent Peguero out the back door.

Fox News reported that Joseph had instructed her clerk to turn off the courtroom's audio recording system during the sidebar, a detail the state's highest court singled out as the basis for the impropriety finding. The court's language was measured, but the facts it described were not: a judge deliberately disabled the official record of her own courtroom at the precise moment she was discussing how to handle a defendant ICE wanted to arrest.

Meanwhile, the broader effort to hold judges accountable for obstructing immigration enforcement continues to gain momentum. Congressional efforts to impeach judges who block federal immigration policy signal that elected officials are no longer content to let the judiciary operate as a one-way shield for illegal immigrants.

Biden dropped the charges; the current DHS is not dropping the issue

The timeline tells the story clearly enough. In 2019, federal prosecutors believed Joseph's conduct warranted three felony counts. By 2022, the Biden administration decided otherwise and let the case collapse. In September, the state's highest court issued a reprimand, a serious mark on a judicial record, but a far cry from the prison time that a felony conviction could have carried.

Joseph's attorney called the prosecution "baseless from the beginning." DHS General Counsel Percival called the underlying conduct a felony. Both cannot be right.

What is clear is that the current administration has drawn a line. Percival's statement was not addressed to Shelley Joseph alone. It was addressed to every judge in every courtroom in every sanctuary jurisdiction who might consider doing what Joseph is accused of doing, turning off the microphone, opening the back door, and letting a twice-deported illegal alien walk past the federal agents sent to enforce the law.

When a judge has to shut off the recording to do what she's about to do, the public has a right to ask whose interests she was serving, and it was not the law's.


About Jenny Curran

Breaking News:

Check This Out:

Heritage Review is a conservative email-newspaper that publishes every morning. Enter your best email to see our next edition: