Former Clinton strategist Mark Penn flags Alaska’s two-Sullivan Senate ballot as fraud

 October 31, 2026

Former Clinton strategist Mark Penn says Alaska’s two-Sullivan Senate ballot is a fake candidacy meant to confuse voters, and outright fraud on the public.

Incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan is running in Alaska against a Democrat who shares the same last name. That dual listing on the ballot drew a sharp public rebuke from Mark Penn, the longtime Democratic operative who once served as a top strategist for former President Bill Clinton and Hillary Clinton.

Just the News reported that Penn laid out his case in a series of posts on X, describing the second Sullivan not as quirky politics but as a deliberate effort to mislead voters.

Penn did not say much about who he believes drove the move, or why it matters in a statewide Senate race.

Penn says a “fake candidate” was recruited to scramble the ballot

In one post, Penn tied the second Sullivan candidacy to Democratic political machinery and a clear purpose: voter confusion.

Penn wrote on X:

"The story of the fake candidacy seems pretty straightforward. The Peltola camp with outreach to the DSCC recruited a fake candidate to confuse voters into voting for the wrong candidate in order to win the election,"

He followed with a harder charge, that the second candidate was not running a real race at all.

Penn continued:

"The candidate has no campaign and has disappeared. This is not election high-jinx but outright fraud on the voters. It cannot stand and no one who okayed this should be elected,"

Those are Penn’s claims. The Just the News account does not include independent filings, campaign-finance records, or statements from election officials confirming fraud. It also does not include responses from Sen. Dan Sullivan, the Democrat also named Sullivan, the Peltola camp, or the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee.

What the reporting does establish is simple and concrete: two Senate candidates named Sullivan appear in the Alaska race, one of them the GOP incumbent, and a former Clinton strategist is publicly calling the arrangement a fake candidacy aimed at confusing voters.

Ranked-choice voting gets the blame for making tricks easier

Penn did not stop at the name collision. He argued Alaska’s ranked-choice voting system makes this kind of ballot gamesmanship easier to pull off, and harder for ordinary voters to sort out.

Ranked-choice voting lets voters rank candidates in order of preference instead of picking one. Supporters sell it as a reform. Penn called it something else entirely, a system do-gooders backed without grasping how easily it can be worked.

He wrote:

"It is a flawed social science experiment and a testament to how do-gooders can be fooled into backing something so easily manipulated. If you are concerned about candidates below 50 or 40 per cent getting elected then add runoffs - those give people a choice that’s clear and gets explored in an election setting,"

His preferred fix was blunt: repeal ranked-choice voting in Alaska and elsewhere, and use clear runoffs when no candidate clears a strong threshold.

Penn also rejected the idea that complaints about other races or other players somehow excuse what he says is happening now.

In another post, he argued:

"Yes, you can complain about others and what they deserve, but it does not excuse this effort now caught red-handed as a blatant attempt to normalize fraud rather than win an election by convincing the voters,"

Name games put the burden on voters, not campaigns

Ballot clarity is not a side issue. When two candidates share a surname in a high-stakes Senate race, the risk is obvious: hurried voters, mail ballots, and low-information choices can send support to the wrong person.

Penn’s account is that this was not an accident of common names. He says the Peltola camp, with outreach to the DSCC, recruited a stand-in Sullivan to siphon or scramble votes, then watched that candidate vanish from any real campaign presence.

Again, those specifics are Penn’s allegations as carried by Just the News. The article does not spell out the Democrat Sullivan’s full ballot name, does not timestamp Penn’s posts beyond the Oct. 31, 2026 publication window, and does not show any court order, elections-office finding, or law-enforcement action labeling the candidacy as fraud.

It does show a seasoned Democratic strategist refusing to shrug the episode off as hardball. Penn called it fraud on the voters and said no one who signed off on it should hold office.

For Alaska voters, the practical problem is the same either way. A Senate ballot with two Sullivans forces people to catch a detail that campaigns can exploit and that busy voters can miss. Ranked-choice rules, in Penn’s view, only widen that opening by layering preference math on top of a name trap.

Honest elections start with ballots people can read without a decoder ring. When operatives treat shared names and tangled voting systems as features, not bugs, voters pay the price, and voices across the aisle are right to say it.


About Tim Harrison

Breaking News:

Check This Out:

Heritage Review is a conservative email-newspaper that publishes every morning. Enter your best email to see our next edition: