White House counsel Will Scharf called the Supreme Court’s June decision on presidential firing power a “generational win,” saying it corrected a long-standing constitutional error.
Speaking Thursday at the Federalist Society’s annual National Lawyers Convention in Washington, Scharf praised the high court’s 6-3 ruling in Trump v. Slaughter and cast it as a long-overdue restoration of executive authority.
The Hill reported that Scharf framed the decision as righting what he called a historic constitutional wrong and ending a weak, outdated limit on the president’s control of the executive branch.
The June ruling allowed President Trump to remove Federal Trade Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter, a Democratic appointee. More broadly, it held that the president may fire the heads of most independent federal agencies at will.
That holding upended a nearly century-old precedent that had insulated those bodies from political interference. The vote fell along ideological lines.
Scharf did not treat the case as a narrow personnel dispute. He tied removal power directly to the Constitution’s vesting of executive authority in one elected president.
He told the Federalist Society audience the Court had fixed a deep structural problem.
“A president who can’t control who’s exercising the executive power that is vested in him, that’s a cabined presidency,”
Scharf said.
In plain terms, he argued that if agency heads can defy the president and keep their jobs anyway, voters lose a clear line of accountability. The people elect one chief executive. Unelected commissioners are not a second executive branch.
He also described the older rule the Court discarded as a “very, very poor and quite ancient precedent.”
For decades, so-called independent agencies operated under special job protections that made it hard for a president to remove their leaders except in limited circumstances. Supporters of that model called it a shield against politics. Critics called it a way to lock in policy after an election is over.
Trump v. Slaughter cut through that arrangement for the heads of most independent federal agencies. The Supreme Court said the president has authority to fire those officials at will. The immediate result in the case was clearance for Trump to sack Slaughter at the FTC.
Scharf celebrated that outcome in blunt terms.
“The Supreme Court did a masterful job,”
he said, adding,
“Really got it right.”
He labeled the ruling a “generational win” and said it righted a “historic constitutional wrong.”
Independent agencies create rules, bring cases, and shape large parts of American economic life. When their leaders cannot be removed by the president, they answer less directly to the voters who just hired or fired that president.
Scharf’s argument tracks a simple chain of responsibility—Congress creates statutes. The president executes the law. Courts interpret the Constitution. If agency chiefs can dig in against the elected executive, the public gets a government that is harder to change at the ballot box.
The Court’s 6-3 decision rejected that insulation model for most independent-agency heads. It did so in a case that began with a concrete removal: Trump’s move against Slaughter at the Federal Trade Commission.
Scharf, speaking as White House counsel to a Federalist Society convention crowd, treated the opinion as more than a win in one personnel fight. He cast it as a structural correction, a return of executive power to the official the Constitution actually vests with it.
Presidents are elected to run the executive branch, not to negotiate with permanent agency barons who answer to no one on Election Day.