The Supreme Court left California's mandatory implicit bias training for doctors in place Monday, a decision Justices Thomas and Alito said lets states cloak compelled speech as government messaging.
Conservative justices warned that California is using medical licensing rules to push private instructors into delivering the state's preferred message on "implicit bias," and the high court refused to take the case.
Courthouse News reported that the Supreme Court declined to review a challenge by ophthalmologist Azadeh Khatibi and the nonprofit Do No Harm to a California rule that forces continuing medical education courses to include training on how implicit bias can contribute to unequal treatment and healthcare disparities. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote a dissent joined by Justice Samuel Alito. Justice Neil Gorsuch said he would have granted the petition.
Lower courts had already thrown out the lawsuit. They treated the mandate as government speech, a category that sits outside ordinary First Amendment limits on compelled speech. That holding left the state free to keep the requirement on the books while private instructors still teach the courses.
The fight is not abstract. California requires licensed doctors to complete continuing education to keep practicing. The state has folded its views on implicit bias into that system. Khatibi teaches those courses. She and Do No Harm argued the rule forces them to carry a contested ideology as the price of staying in the profession.
The Washington Examiner noted that Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch would have taken up Khatibi v. Yip, falling one justice short of the four votes needed to hear arguments. The denial leaves California's mandate standing for now. >
Thomas did not treat the loss as a technical footnote. He attacked the way the Ninth Circuit stretched the government-speech doctrine so far that heavy regulation of a field can strip private teachers of First Amendment protection.
He wrote that a state cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny.
"We should not permit the government-speech doctrine to be wielded as ‘a cover for censorship’ or a cloak for compelled speech."
That warning sits at the center of the conservative critique. If the government can label enough private instruction as its own message, the First Amendment becomes a formality for anyone who needs a state license to work.
Thomas has long pressed the Court to police doctrines that expand government power over speech and constitutional limits, including in fights over precedent he has criticized for decades. Monday's dissent fits that pattern.
The appeals court said California used education requirements to communicate its views on medical practices even though private instructors deliver the classes. Thomas rejected that logic as a blank check.
"Applying the Ninth Circuit’s logic, enough government regulation of the field would convert the private speaker’s message in each of these hypotheticals into government speech unprotected by the First Amendment."
He added that the result does not follow from the Court's precedents, and it certainly does not follow from the Constitution.
In plain terms, the state is not merely speaking for itself. It is telling private professionals what they must say in order to keep teaching and practicing. Thomas drew a hard line between the government as speaker and the government as regulator.
"The challenged government activity must be ‘government speech in the literal sense, purposeful communication of a governmentally determined message by a person acting within the scope of a power to speak for the government.’"
And he stressed the limit that follows:
"Moreover, ‘the government must... not rely on a means that abridges the speech of persons acting in a private capacity,’ because doing so reveals that the government has moved from the role of speaker to that of regulator."
Alito's decision to join that dissent keeps him aligned with Thomas on free-speech fights that reach the Court, even as Democrats and critics keep pressure on both men over ethics and tenure questions of the kind covered when Alito said he would remain on the Court.
The requirement did not appear out of thin air. A Ninth Circuit panel earlier upheld California's AB 241 rule requiring implicit bias content inside continuing medical education that doctors need to keep their licenses. Doctors in the state must complete 50 hours of accredited CME every two years, and the training is part of that system.
Just the News reported that the Pacific Legal Foundation planned to seek full-court rehearing for Khatibi, warning the decision expands compelled ideological speech across multiple Western states and professions. The circuit's reach covers California, Oregon, Washington, Nevada, Arizona, Idaho, Alaska, Montana, and Hawaii.
Caleb Trotter of the Pacific Legal Foundation put the stakes bluntly after the appeals court ruled.
"there is little to stop governments around the country from compelling continuing education instructors in any trade or profession to profess all manner of controversial state-endorsed topics."
The foundation also said Khatibi never imagined she would escape the oppression of her childhood only to face creeping collectivism and unfree speech in America. That framing treats the mandate as ideology enforced through the license, not neutral professional hygiene.
The lower courts dismissed scientific disputes over implicit bias itself. They leaned instead on California's long history of regulating medical education and on the government-speech label. Thomas's dissent says that history and that label do not erase the First Amendment when the state drafts private speakers.
With the Supreme Court declining review, California keeps the power to require the training. Instructors who want to teach accredited courses still face the content rule. Doctors who need those credits to renew licenses still operate inside a system that treats contested social theory as a condition of professional life.
That outcome matters beyond one specialty. Once "government speech" covers private CME instructors because the state regulates the field, the same logic can travel. Law, nursing, teaching, real estate, and other licensed trades all run on continuing education. A doctrine that converts private classroom speech into unprotected state messaging invites copycats.
Thomas and Alito are often the Court's most consistent votes against expansive speech controls, a record that also shows up when Thomas has praised allies who resist political attacks on the Court. Gorsuch's willingness to grant review added a third vote. Four were required. They did not get it.
The case arrived after two lower courts dismissed the challenge on government-speech grounds. The Ninth Circuit's approach treated California's education rules as a vehicle for the state's own message. Thomas answered that enough regulation cannot launder a speech mandate.
Political fights over the Court's membership and future appointments keep returning to the same names. Coverage of how Alito has stayed put amid Senate shifts underlines why each free-speech dissent from the conservative wing still draws national attention. Monday's order did not change the law. The dissent put the constitutional objection on the record.
Thomas also issued a statement the same day on a Maryland case involving so-called sensitive-place bans on firearms. An appeals court had upheld a Maryland law barring guns from public demonstrations, mass transit, places of amusement, healthcare facilities, locations that sell alcohol for onsite consumption, and state parks and forest land. The Supreme Court turned down gun owners who sought review.
Thomas said the Court was right to deny that petition because the challenge was too broad. He still flagged the deeper issue.
"I harbor serious doubts that our nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation supports many of these sweeping restrictions."
He wrote that in an appropriate case, the Court should consider whether particular sensitive-place laws are consistent with the right to public carry. He pointed to expansive place restrictions in states including New Jersey, New York, and California. That statement is separate from the medical-education fight. It shows the same justice pressing the Court not to leave major constitutional limits untested when states push hard.
Succession politics around Thomas and Alito remain a live topic in conservative circles, including claims that Democrats holding the Senate would freeze future Court picks. The immediate fight Monday was narrower: whether California can force private medical educators to teach the state's bias curriculum under the shield of government speech.
Implicit bias training has become a preferred tool for institutions that want to lock in a contested theory of unequal treatment without winning a clean public debate. California folded that theory into the CME system doctors cannot ignore if they want to keep practicing. Khatibi and Do No Harm tried to stop it on free-speech grounds. The Ninth Circuit called it government speech. The Supreme Court walked away.
Thomas's dissent refuses the euphemism. When the state uses licensing and course rules to make private people deliver its message, it is regulating speech, not merely speaking. Alito signed on. Gorsuch would have heard the case. The rest of the Court left the mandate in force.
Taxpayers and patients get a medical system steered by politics dressed up as professional education. Doctors and instructors get a choice that is not really a choice: recite the state's line or step out of accredited teaching and, downstream, risk the credits that keep a license current. That is how soft compulsion works in a regulated profession.
The Constitution still draws a line between the government talking and the government making others talk. Monday's order left California on the wrong side of that line without a full hearing. Thomas and Alito put the warning in writing. The next state watching the Ninth Circuit now has a roadmap unless a later case finally forces the Court to draw the boundary Thomas described.