Dozens of FBI agents and Justice Department lawyers are digging into Democrat Mary Peltola’s projected Alaska Senate victory after allegations her side recruited a spoiler named Dan Sullivan to confuse voters.
Fox News projects that Democrat Mary Peltola has defeated Republican incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan in Alaska’s U.S. Senate race, flipping a GOP-held seat as the Associated Press called the contest for her with 50.1 percent of the vote. The projected win comes while senior Justice Department officials have already opened a criminal investigation into her campaign and Democratic operatives over the alleged recruitment of a third candidate with nearly the same name: Daniel J. Sullivan, known as “Decoy Dan.”
Fox News reported that at least 50 FBI agents and more than a dozen DOJ lawyers are working the case, with more than 200 subpoenas issued, nearly 100 preservation letters sent, and at least five field offices involved. A federal grand jury in Alaska is meeting once a month to review evidence. An ally close to Attorney General Todd Blanche said Blanche views the matter as so serious that he is pouring substantial resources into the criminal probe.
Peltola received 144,486 votes to Sullivan’s 131,965, according to the AP tallies cited in the reporting. Republican third candidate Gerald Heikes took 6,105 votes, while all other candidates, including Daniel J. Sullivan, combined for 5,561. Alaska officials have not yet certified the totals; they had previously eyed Nov. 25 as a target date. The Justice Department had filed a civil lawsuit seeking to delay certification, but now treats that suit as moot because the votes have been counted.
A New York Times report released in October claimed that Peltola campaign staffers and senior aides at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee jointly plotted to get Daniel J. Sullivan on the ballot in an effort to confuse voters. The DSCC denied involvement. The Peltola campaign did not immediately respond to requests for comment in the initial coverage.
Sen. Dan Sullivan has been blunt about what he says happened. He has described a long-running effort that his opponent later denied.
"This was a secret project that they had. And then they worked on it for over a year. And then she consistently lied about it,"
Peltola has rejected any claim that she knew about or backed a decoy. Speaking to supporters in Juneau in October, she insisted she had no knowledge of other candidates beyond herself and the incumbent.
"I just want to clear the air,"
She continued:
"I knew nothing about any other candidates on the ballot except for me and the incumbent. That is all I have ever known about. I am not interested in tricking voters. I know I can beat Dan Sullivan,"
She launched her Senate campaign on Jan. 17, 2026, in Anchorage and spoke again at an election-night event there on Tuesday, Nov. 3, 2026, as the AP projection landed.
Just the News reported that the Justice Department has issued more than 200 subpoenas in a multi-state criminal probe into the Alaska Senate race involving the two candidates named Dan Sullivan. The investigation focuses on the Peltola campaign and the DSCC. High-profile elections attorney Marc Elias, whose firm represents the Peltola campaign, was among those who received a preservation letter; additional reporting has described him as receiving a target letter as the probe advanced.
The Justice Department declined to comment. Congressional Republicans have also opened related inquiries. The scale, agents, lawyers, subpoenas, preservation demands, and a sitting grand jury, shows federal prosecutors treating the alleged recruitment of a same-name candidate as more than a campaign-trail stunt.
The alleged scheme did not stay confined to Alaska operatives. The Washington Free Beacon reported that days after Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer’s side denied ties to Daniel J. Sullivan’s campaign, the Schumer-aligned nonprofit Majority Forward began running an ad featuring Alan Harris. Harris had delivered Dan J. Sullivan’s candidacy declaration on June 1. Harris is the romantic partner of Democratic strategist Amber Lee, who had prior links to Mary Peltola and was hired as a campaign adviser to the decoy candidate.
Schumer’s apparatus and Senate Majority PAC denied involvement on June 7. The Majority Forward ad began airing on June 16. A spokesman for Senate Majority PAC said neither the PAC nor Majority Forward had ever communicated with Dan J. Sullivan, directly or indirectly, and claimed both entities were unaware that a person featured in the ad was involved with that campaign. The group said the video was filmed in early May, before Sullivan filed.
That sequence undercuts the clean separation Democrats tried to draw. A denial one week, an ad the next featuring the man who filed the decoy’s paperwork, and a Peltola-linked strategist advising the same candidate leave a trail that investigators can follow.
Even with the AP projection and the Fox News call, Alaska’s election totals remain uncertified. The DOJ’s earlier civil effort to pause certification has been set aside as moot now that ballots are counted. What remains is the criminal track: subpoenas aimed at the Peltola campaign and the DSCC, preservation letters to figures including Marc Elias, agents across multiple field offices, and a grand jury in Alaska reviewing evidence on a monthly cycle.
Peltola’s campaign has maintained she knew nothing about any decoy and that she needed no tricks to beat Sullivan. Sullivan says the project ran more than a year in secret and that she lied about it afterward. The New York Times account of joint plotting by campaign staffers and DSCC aides sits between those two positions. The Justice Department is testing which version matches the records now under subpoena.
Voters in Alaska chose a new senator under rules that already allow ranked-choice complexity. Adding a candidate who shares the incumbent’s name raises a basic fairness question that does not depend on party labels. When federal agents, more than a dozen DOJ lawyers, hundreds of subpoenas, and a grand jury all move at once, the allegation has left the realm of campaign spin.
Democratic operatives who treat ballot confusion as strategy should not be surprised when prosecutors treat it as a case file. Accountability does not stop at the water’s edge of a projected win.