Hochul's pardon of convicted felon kills Supreme Court immigration case before oral argument

 September 12, 2026

New York Gov. Kathy Hochul pardoned a convicted felon just as the Trump administration's Supreme Court brief was due, a move that torpedoed a major case on bond rights for detained noncitizens and drew sharp criticism from state officials.

The Supreme Court will no longer hear oral argument in Genalo v. Black, a case that could have settled whether the federal government must offer bond hearings to noncitizens held in lengthy immigration detention. Solicitor General John Sauer agreed Friday that the case is now moot, Fox News Digital reported, after Hochul issued a pardon in late August to Keisy Guerrero Mariano, a lawfully present Dominican citizen who had pleaded guilty to second-degree assault in 2015.

The timing was not subtle. Hochul issued the pardon just as the administration's brief was due to the court, effectively removing Mariano from the case and stripping the justices of a live controversy to decide. The court had agreed to hear the case on June 15, setting the stage for a significant ruling on immigration detention authority. Hochul, who opposes President Donald Trump's immigration enforcement efforts, used her pardon power to ensure that ruling never came.

Hochul shielded a convicted felon from deportation, and from the Supreme Court

Mariano, identified in court documents as "Keisy GM," was first arrested by ICE in 2020 over the 2015 assault conviction. He spent nearly two years in immigration detention before being released in 2022 under a nationwide COVID-19 injunction that required federal authorities to free detainees due to health risks in detention facilities.

In November 2021, while Mariano was still detained, Judge John P. Cronan of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York denied his request for a writ of habeas corpus, the legal mechanism a detainee uses to challenge being held without a hearing. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals overruled Cronan in May 2024, finding that the government must grant noncitizens a bond hearing once detention becomes "unreasonably long." The appeals court said that failing to provide such a hearing violates the Fifth Amendment's guarantee of due process.

The Trump administration challenged that ruling, arguing that noncitizens, including those with green card status, do not have a legal right to a bond hearing during prolonged detention if they have committed crimes that are grounds for mandatory deportation. The Supreme Court's decision to take the case signaled that the justices were prepared to weigh in on a question with broad consequences for immigration enforcement nationwide.

Hochul's pardon eliminated Mariano as a party with standing, and the case collapsed. The other plaintiff, Carol Williams Black, a Jamaican national convicted in New York in 2000 of sexually abusing a minor under the age of 11, had already been ruled moot after he left the United States and filed a court declaration that he would not return. With both plaintiffs gone, the court had no case left to decide.

The governor's office has not publicly explained the legal basis for the pardon. Fox News Digital reached out to Hochul's office for comment but received no quoted response.

Iowa's solicitor general calls the pardon 'pretty wild'

Eric Wessan, Iowa's solicitor general, posted his reaction on X, calling out the governor's decision in blunt terms.

"Pretty wild to fully pardon an aggravated felon to (1) stop the felon from getting deported and (2) stop the Supreme Court from ruling on an issue. (Especially as this litigation has been going on for years)"

Wessan followed up with a broader question about the precedent Hochul's move sets for other governors sympathetic to illegal immigrants facing deportation proceedings.

"I wonder how many non-American felons Governors like Hochul will choose to fully pardon and free to avoid them facing consequences for their actions"

The question is not rhetorical. If a governor can pardon a convicted felon to strip the Supreme Court of jurisdiction over a live immigration case, there is nothing in principle stopping other governors from doing the same thing in future cases. The pardon power is broad, and Hochul used it not to correct an injustice but to obstruct a federal proceeding, shielding a convicted violent offender from both deportation and judicial review.

In a criminal justice system where consequences are supposed to follow convictions, the governor's decision stands out. While debates over clemency and executive power are as old as the republic, pardons are traditionally reserved for cases involving mitigating circumstances, rehabilitation, or manifest injustice, not for the purpose of derailing a pending Supreme Court case on federal immigration authority.

Sauer pledges to find a new path to the Supreme Court

Sauer did not concede the underlying legal question. While agreeing that Genalo v. Black is moot, he stated that the Trump administration will seek an "alternative vehicle" to bring the Second Circuit's 2024 ruling back before the justices. The administration's goal is to find another case through which the Supreme Court can resolve the bond-hearing issue during its 2026, 27 term.

That means the legal fight is delayed, not over. But the delay matters. The Second Circuit's ruling, requiring bond hearings for noncitizens held in prolonged detention, remains in effect across its jurisdiction, which covers New York, Connecticut, and Vermont. Every month the ruling stands unchallenged, it shapes how ICE handles detention and removal proceedings in one of the most immigration-heavy regions in the country.

The Supreme Court's willingness to take up criminal justice cases this term has already been significant, but losing Genalo v. Black before oral argument is a procedural setback for the administration. Finding a new case with proper standing, shepherding it through the lower courts, and getting the justices to grant review again will take time, time that benefits those who want the Second Circuit's expansive reading of due process protections for detained noncitizens to remain the law.

A pardon designed to protect a policy, not a person

Hochul's pardon did not correct a wrongful conviction. Mariano pleaded guilty. He served time for second-degree assault. ICE detained him based on that conviction. A federal judge denied his habeas petition. The system worked as designed at every step, until the governor intervened to remove a convicted violent offender from the reach of federal immigration enforcement and, simultaneously, from the Supreme Court's docket.

The practical result is that a lawfully present noncitizen who committed a violent felony now walks free with a clean record, courtesy of a governor who opposes the federal government's authority to detain and deport criminal aliens. The legal result is that a case the justices had already agreed to hear, one that could have clarified the rights of detained noncitizens nationwide, vanished before a single word of oral argument.

Cases involving the intersection of criminal sentencing and immigration detention are not abstractions. They determine whether ICE can hold convicted criminals during removal proceedings or must release them into American communities. The Second Circuit's ruling tilts that balance toward release. Hochul's pardon ensured the Supreme Court could not tilt it back, at least not yet.

Meanwhile, the broader pattern of federal courts and state executives clashing over criminal justice authority continues to grow. DHS general counsel James Percival has warned of what he calls an "epidemic of judicial activism," pointing to cases where federal judges have ordered the release of individuals the government considers dangerous. Hochul's pardon is not judicial activism, it is executive activism, deployed to achieve the same end.

Sauer says the administration will find another vehicle. It will have to. Governors who are willing to pardon convicted felons to block Supreme Court rulings have found a new tool, and the only check on it is the political cost they are willing to pay.

When a governor uses the pardon pen not to deliver justice but to obstruct it, the question stops being about one felon's bond hearing. It becomes about whether any state executive can unilaterally shut down federal law enforcement by erasing the convictions that make it possible.


About Owen Bates

Breaking News:

Check This Out:

Heritage Review is a conservative email-newspaper that publishes every morning. Enter your best email to see our next edition: