House passes stock trading ban for Congress, but the bill leaves gaping loopholes and a voter ID fight

 July 26, 2026

The House approved a bill banning members of Congress from buying individual stocks, but critics on both sides say the measure is too weak, and a voter ID provision attached to it has all but guaranteed a Senate standoff.

Lawmakers voted 232, 198 on July 22 to pass the Stop Insider Trading Act, a bill introduced by Rep. Bryan Steil of Wisconsin that bars sitting members of Congress, their spouses, and dependent children from purchasing individual stocks while in office. Thirteen Democrats crossed party lines to join every Republican in favor, the Daily Caller reported. The remaining 198 Democrats voted no.

The bill does not require lawmakers to sell stocks they already own. Members can keep their existing portfolios and continue selling shares, provided they file public notice seven to fourteen days in advance. Penalties for violating disclosure rules would jump from a current $200 fine to $2,000 or 10 percent of the transaction's value, whichever is greater.

That gap between "ban" and reality drew fire from the left and the right alike. And the voter ID provision Republicans attached to the bill turned a broadly popular reform into a partisan grenade, exactly the outcome at least one Republican member predicted.

86 percent of Americans wanted this, Congress gave them half

Public frustration with congressional stock trading has been building for years. A 2023 poll by the University of Maryland's Program for Public Consultation found that 86 percent of Americans support banning lawmakers from trading stocks, 87 percent of Republicans, 88 percent of Democrats, and 81 percent of independents. The same survey found 87 percent want the ban extended to the president, vice president, and Supreme Court justices.

Congress first tried to address the issue in 2012 with the STOCK Act, which required lawmakers to disclose trades promptly. That law has been widely regarded as toothless, the first-offense penalty was just $200, and enforcement has been virtually nonexistent.

The Stop Insider Trading Act raises those penalties, but it still does not force members to divest. A lawmaker who entered Congress holding millions in individual stocks could sit on that portfolio for an entire career, selling when convenient, while voting on legislation that affects those same companies.

Rep. Jim McGovern, a Massachusetts Democrat, posted on X that the bill amounts to a "watered-down" half-measure:

"Correcting the Record: your s*****, watered-down bill is a band-aid on a bullet hole. It does NOT ban stock trading. It bans Members of Congress from BUYING stocks but not SELLING them. Nice loophole."

McGovern's language was crude, but the underlying point is not easy to dismiss. A member who already holds a large position in, say, a defense contractor can still sell that stock after sitting in a classified briefing, and the bill would allow it as long as the member files notice a week ahead of time.

AP News reported that the bill also exempts the president and vice president from the trading ban entirely. That detail is notable given that President Trump made more than 3,600 buy and sell orders in the first quarter of this year alone, according to AP's reporting.

Voter ID turned a popular bill into a partisan weapon

Before the bill reached the floor, House Republicans added a voter ID requirement for federal elections. Under the provision, voters must present a valid physical photo ID to receive a regular ballot. Those without acceptable identification could cast a provisional ballot, which would count only if they submit qualifying ID, or a sworn religious-objection affidavit, within three days.

Democrats immediately accused Republicans of sabotaging the stock trading ban by tying it to an unrelated election-integrity measure they knew most Democrats would oppose. Rep. Joseph Morelle of New York called the voter ID provision a "poison pill" and told Politico that Republicans had "corrupted their so-called stock trading bill with a decaying piece of the SAVE America Act corpse."

Rep. Marie Gluesenkamp Perez of Washington, one of the thirteen Democrats who voted yes, still objected to the attachment. She posted on X that "House Republicans took a broadly nonpartisan issue and inserted politics, provisions from the Save America Act. I've voted against these voter ID provisions repeatedly and Senate Republicans have made clear this has no path in the Senate."

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez went further, calling the package a "GOP effort to sabotage national mail-in voting, disguised as a trading ban," the New York Post reported.

The most pointed criticism came from inside the Republican conference. Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky, who voted for the bill, accused his own party of a cynical maneuver. He posted on X:

"Congress is not serious. We are voting on a stock trading ban for members of Congress... BUT Republicans added voter-ID in the legislation. Not to get Dems to vote for voter-ID, but to get them to vote against the stock trading ban, so they can use it in the Nov. election."

Massie's allegation is worth sitting with. If he is right, the voter ID provision was never meant to become law, it was meant to give Republicans a campaign ad. That would mean the stock trading ban itself was secondary to the political play, and the 86 percent of Americans who support the reform were used as props.

Republicans counter: two popular ideas belong together

Republican leadership framed the combined bill differently. House Speaker Mike Johnson said the vote represented a step toward restoring public trust.

"For too long, Americans struggling to make ends meet have watched as lawmakers have entered office just to leave as multi-millionaires. Today, with passage of the Stop Insider Trading Act, House Republicans took a critically important step to restore that faith and trust in both Congress and American elections."

Rep. Zach Nunn of Iowa, as Fox News reported, put it more bluntly: "Only in Washington can you have two wins for 90% of Americans, and Democrats will say that's one win too many."

Rep. Stephanie Bice of Oklahoma added: "The American people deserve to know their elected officials are serving the public, not their own financial interests."

Sen. Pete Ricketts of Nebraska, who introduced a Senate companion bill, defended the scope of the ban on CNBC's Squawk Box. Responding to criticism that the bill does not go far enough, Ricketts said: "What we want to do is make sure we're not locking out people who come from a successful business. We don't want to keep a successful business person from coming to Congress."

That argument has some merit. Forcing a business owner to liquidate an entire portfolio before taking office could discourage qualified candidates from running. But it does not answer the central complaint: that lawmakers who keep and sell individual stocks still face the same conflicts of interest that made the public demand a ban in the first place.

One Nevada Democrat's vote carried its own baggage

Among the thirteen Democrats who crossed party lines, Rep. Susie Lee of Nevada stood out. Breitbart reported that Lee voted for the ban days after scrutiny over a trust linked to her that sold between $500,000 and $1 million in Full House Resorts stock roughly two weeks before shares dropped approximately 25 percent, a move that may have avoided up to $300,000 in losses.

A spokesperson for Lee said she "is currently in the process of transferring individual holdings she received following her divorce, including shares of Full House Resorts, Inc., into ETFs, index funds, and mutual funds, going above and beyond what's required of her by law and ethics rules." The timing, however, underscores exactly the kind of suspicion that has dogged lawmakers of both parties for years.

Senate path remains unclear, and the filibuster looms

The bill now moves to the Senate, where its prospects are uncertain at best. The voter ID provision would need 60 votes to clear a filibuster, and Democrats have signaled they will not provide them. Whether Senate Republicans attempt to strip the voter ID language to pass the stock trading ban on its own, or keep the package intact and dare Democrats to block it, remains an open question.

Just The News noted that a stricter Senate companion bill already exists, one that would ban members of Congress, their families, the president, and vice president from owning or trading any individual stocks. That version goes well beyond the House bill, but it faces its own political obstacles.

The House vote came the same day Speaker Johnson's roughly $95 billion reconciliation framework, which included provisions tied to the SAVE America Act, cleared the chamber. The legislative calendar is crowded, and the August recess is approaching. If the Senate does not act before the break, momentum could stall.

Rep. Mike Lawler of New York, a Republican, framed the stakes simply: "Banning congressional stock trading is a simple proposition: If you serve the public, you serve only the public."

Fourteen years after the STOCK Act proved that disclosure without enforcement is meaningless, and three years after a poll showed near-universal public support for a real ban, Congress produced a bill that bans buying but not selling, exempts existing portfolios, skips the president entirely, and arrives gift-wrapped with a provision designed to make the other party vote no. The history of insider trading in Congress is long enough that voters have earned the right to be skeptical.

When 86 percent of the country agrees on something and Washington still can't deliver a clean bill, the problem isn't partisan, it's institutional. And no amount of campaign ads will fix that.


About Tim Harrison

Breaking News:

Check This Out:

Heritage Review is a conservative email-newspaper that publishes every morning. Enter your best email to see our next edition: