Long Island Democratic chairman under FBI scrutiny backs off 30% raise after residents revolt

 November 16, 2026

A Suffolk County Democratic boss facing an FBI probe over alleged vote-buying pushed a 30% taxpayer-funded raise for himself, until angry Babylon residents forced a pay cut instead.

Babylon Town Supervisor Rich Schaffer, who also chairs the Suffolk County Democratic Party, unveiled a budget on Oct. 15 that would have handed him a $36,000 salary increase, nearly 30%, while asking local property owners to absorb a nearly 6% tax hike.

Other elected town officials stood to gain raises ranging from 5% to more than 13%. Residents saw the package as self-dealing at a moment when Schaffer was already under federal scrutiny, and they made that plain at a Nov. 5 town board meeting.

More than two dozen people turned out to protest. One resident confronted him directly over the optics of the request while federal and state investigators were looking at him.

"We’re being asked to pay for a 29% salary increase for you as you are actively being investigated by the federal and state [agencies] for corruption,"

Another resident tied the tax hike straight to the probe and questioned where the money would go.

"How dare you raise our taxes by that much, where is that money going? To you? You’re being investigated by the FBI, is that what you need the money for? For your legal fees?"

The New York Post reported that Schaffer is being probed by the FBI for alleged vote-buying and for allegedly running a Mafia-style campaign to keep his hold on the Democratic Party chairmanship. No charges are described as filed, and the allegations remain just that, allegations. Schaffer and the town of Babylon did not respond to the Post’s request for comment.

The same federal interest in Long Island Democratic leadership has already drawn sharp political pushback from Albany, including when Hochul dismissed the FBI probe of the Suffolk Dem chairman as a political hit job over vote-buying claims.

Residents force the budget rewrite

About a week after the Nov. 5 grilling, the town announced it would revise the budget and strip out the raises for Schaffer and the other elected officials. Schaffer agreed to cut his own town supervisor pay by a little over $3,000 a year, bringing the supervisor salary to $120,000.

He still collects pay as Democratic Party chairman and from a private law practice. The climb-down landed just one week after Democrats nationally took control of the House and Senate, a timing detail that underscored how local taxpayers, not party momentum, dictated the outcome in Babylon.

Schaffer later told Newsday the public had gotten through.

"Message received"

He added a fuller explanation of why he moved.

"I believe that I as the leader have to not only take action to correct that but also show that I understand the concerns that have been expressed."

That sequence, propose a large personal raise and a tax increase first, reverse course only after public shaming, is the conduct residents measured. The town’s own revision removed the raises across the board after the meeting made the political cost obvious.

Federal heat meets local tax bills

Schaffer’s dual role as town supervisor and county party boss put him at the center of both the budget fight and the broader investigation narrative. Residents at the meeting treated the FBI interest as settled fact in their remarks; official charging documents or agency confirmations of scope were not laid out in the reporting. What was concrete was the budget math: a $36,000 bump for the supervisor, smaller but still sizable hikes for at least three other town leaders, and a nearly 6% property tax increase stacked on top.

Pressure on blue-state political machines has become a recurring theme in national coverage, including when Trump redirected focus toward blue-state corruption crackdowns as a priority track alongside other federal business.

In New York, the FBI’s attention on the Suffolk chairman has already produced separate clashes with the governor’s office. The bureau has pushed back when the probe was cast as partisan theater, a dispute captured when the FBI rebuked Hochul for branding the Long Island Dem boss investigation a political hit job.

Party wins did not buy local cover

Schaffer’s pay-cut announcement arrived on the heels of a strong national night for Democrats. That backdrop did not soften the town-level reaction. Babylon residents were not debating House and Senate control; they were staring at a proposed tax hike and a supervisor raise while hearing that their town executive faced federal questions about how he held party power.

National Democrats, flush with midterm gains, have separately floated aggressive oversight tools of their own, from a Colorado Democrat floating impeachment as a post-midterms tool to other members keeping similar options in reserve. None of that Washington talk paid Schaffer’s local bills or quieted the Nov. 5 room.

The town’s revised budget dropped the elected-official raises. Schaffer’s supervisor salary moved to $120,000 after the modest cut. The nearly 6% property tax proposal and the original raise package were the flashpoint; the public meeting and the subsequent retreat were the resolution the record shows.

Accountability arrived from the audience, not the party

No primary budget text or roll-call vote was reproduced in the available reporting, and the precise pre-raise baseline salary was not fully itemized beyond the $36,000 increase sought and the later cut to $120,000. What stands is the sequence of actions: the Oct. 15 proposal, the Nov. 5 confrontation, the revision stripping the raises, and Schaffer’s acknowledgment that the message had landed.

Taxpayers in Babylon did not need a lengthy ethics lecture. They saw a party chairman under FBI examination for alleged vote-buying ask for a large raise funded by a tax increase, and they rejected it in public. The raise died. The pay cut followed. That is how local accountability worked in this case, through residents who showed up and refused to underwrite the request.

When officials under federal scrutiny reach for bigger taxpayer checks, voters still get the final word at the microphone.


About Owen Bates

Breaking News:

Check This Out:

Heritage Review is a conservative email-newspaper that publishes every morning. Enter your best email to see our next edition: