New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani attended the 9/11 remembrance ceremony at Ground Zero despite more than 110,000 petition signatures demanding he stay away, and the families of the fallen made clear he was not welcome.
Mamdani walked into the 25th-anniversary service at the Twin Towers site in Lower Manhattan on Friday, brushing past weeks of public opposition from victims' relatives, former city leaders, and first responders who said his presence dishonored the dead. Walter Matuza, a Staten Island resident whose father was killed when American Airlines Flight 11 struck the north tower, helped launch the petition drive to keep the mayor away.
"He showed up anyway. It does bother us," Matuza told Fox News Digital at the memorial. His father, also named Walter Matuza, worked at Carr Futures brokerage on the 92nd floor of the north tower. Dozens of his coworkers died that morning.
The petition, organized by a group of victims' families, had collected more than 110,000 signatures by the time Mamdani took his seat at the ceremony. Former New York Governor George Pataki and former FDNY Commissioner Thomas von Essen, both of whom served during the 2001 attacks, had publicly called on the mayor to skip the event.
He ignored them all.
The opposition did not emerge from nowhere. Critics have pointed to Mamdani's appointment of Ramzi Kassem as his administration's chief counsel. Kassem previously represented a Guantánamo Bay detainee described as linked to an al Qaeda terrorist plot. That hire, combined with Mamdani's described association with streamer Hasan Piker, who once said America "deserved 9/11", gave mourners a specific, personal reason to object.
Mike, a former New Jersey police officer who watched the towers fall from across the Hudson River on September 11, 2001, said the mayor's record spoke for itself.
"Based on the rhetoric that he's used in the past. Yeah, he probably should have skipped it."
Mike later came to Manhattan that day in 2001 to help relieve exhausted NYPD officers. He told Fox News Digital that Mamdani could have handled the Kassem appointment in a "whole different way", and that the mayor's decision to attend the ceremony compounded the damage.
"But, he did it and unfortunately people aren't going to forget it."
Mamdani is no stranger to hostile public receptions. Earlier this year, a Staten Island crowd booed him off stage at an NYPD celebration in under a minute.
Steven, who traveled from Hobe Sound, Florida, to attend the remembrance, said he had followed the petition controversy for weeks. He acknowledged Mamdani's legal right to be present but questioned the mayor's judgment in exercising it.
"I mean, as the mayor, I would assume he has the right to be here.... But who he represents and the people he's affiliated with... I feel that he should stay away. I don't feel that his presence here is wanted, and I think he should honor that as a human being."
Steven called the Kassem appointment "hideous" and said he came to the memorial in part to teach his children about what happened on September 11, 2001. The ceremony marked 25 years since the attacks that killed nearly 3,000 people, including more than 650 employees of Cantor Fitzgerald alone, the most of any single company in the Twin Towers that day.
Mamdani's conduct has drawn sustained criticism on multiple fronts. His rhetoric has been blamed for contributing to a rise in anti-Jewish hate crimes across the city, and resurfaced recordings have only added to the scrutiny.
Not every attendee shared the same level of anger. John, who lost friends at Cantor Fitzgerald on 9/11, said he was "fine" with the mayor attending as long as Mamdani showed respect to the fallen Americans being remembered. But John's was a minority voice among those who spoke at the site.
Footage from the ceremony captured Mamdani approaching and greeting Rudolph Giuliani, the Republican mayor who led New York through the 2001 attacks. Giuliani appeared to exchange brief pleasantries before turning and sitting down. An aide then began speaking to Mamdani.
In a statement issued before the ceremony, Mamdani framed his attendance around the families and first responders.
"[W]hat I want this week to be a focus on is on the families whose loved ones were stolen from them 25 years ago in the horrific act of terror of September 11, and a focus also on the first responders who gave everything they could to this city and to the people who came together to try and help their fellow New Yorkers."
The mayor also said he is proud of New York and "love[s] this city [and] country." Fox News Digital reached out to Mamdani for additional comment; no response was reported.
Separately, resurfaced clips from 2016 have drawn fresh mockery of the mayor, adding to a pattern of controversies that have dogged his tenure.
President Trump did not attend the Ground Zero ceremony. He visited the Pentagon's separate 9/11 remembrance before departing from nearby Andrews Air Force Base for County Clare, Ireland. All living former presidents reportedly attended the Lower Manhattan service.
Mamdani's decision to attend also comes after he publicly mourned an accused killer's death at Rikers while the victim's family said he never mentioned their son, another episode that revealed where the mayor's sympathies tend to land.
The petition's tally stood at more than 110,000 signatures. Mourner Steven cited a figure of "upwards of 700,000," though the petition's own count did not support that number. Regardless of the precise total, the message from victims' families was unambiguous: stay home.
Mamdani chose to show up anyway. He framed his attendance as solidarity with the families of the dead. The families of the dead told him, in writing and in person, that they did not want his solidarity.
When 110,000 people sign a petition asking you not to come to a funeral, and you come anyway, the word for that is not leadership. It is exactly what the mourners called it: disrespectful.