Ninth Circuit rejects law firm challenge to Trump diversity visa pause

 October 30, 2026

The Ninth Circuit handed Trump an immigration win by rejecting a law firm’s challenge to the diversity visa freeze, and warned of ‘floodgates’ if lawyers could sue on thin claims.

A 2-1 panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals blocked a lower-court order that would have forced the State Department to reopen the 2027 Diversity Visa lottery application pool.

The decision stops enforcement of a preliminary injunction from U.S. District Judge Jinsook Ohta. Immigration law firm Red Eagle had sued to compel the government to accept new lottery entries. The appeals court held the firm lacked standing to bring the case.

Fox News reported the panel’s core warning on what would follow if a law firm could sue over its own business interests in the program.

"If Red Eagle Law were allowed to allege standing based upon its hypothetical or conjectural collateral injury, we would be opening the floodgates, allowing all lawyers to ‘roam the country in search of governmental wrongdoing.’"

That line framed the case as a procedural gatekeeping fight, not a free-for-all for every firm that makes money on immigration paperwork.

State Department froze the lottery after a campus massacre

Secretary of State Marco Rubio issued a November notice delaying new applications for the 2027 Diversity Visa lottery so the department could “implement certain changes.” The application window never opened.

A month later, the State Department ordered an indefinite pause on issuing diversity visas. The move followed the Brown University mass shooting in Providence, Rhode Island, tied to a Portuguese national who entered on a 2017 diversity lottery visa.

Claudio Manuel Neves Valente killed two people and injured nine others in that attack. Authorities also linked him to the murder of a Massachusetts Institute of Technology professor two days later.

The Diversity Visa lottery admits roughly 55,000 immigrants a year from countries with historically low U.S. immigration. Entry is by chance, not by job skill, education, or security vetting beyond baseline checks. Countries listed as eligible for the 2026 round included Afghanistan, Iran, Somalia, Uganda, Russia, Ecuador, and New Zealand.

President Trump has attacked the program for years. In his January 2018 State of the Union address, he called for ending it and shifting to merit-based visas. In a bipartisan White House meeting that same month, he said lottery visas let in the “worst of the worst.”

He put the problem in plain terms.

"They call it ‘visa lottery,’ I just call it ‘lottery.’ But countries come in and they put names in a hopper. They’re not giving you their best names; common sense means they’re not giving you their best names."

His administration revoked 100,000 visas in 2025 while pressing harder screening across multiple visa categories.

Judges refused to let a firm sue for its own fees

Red Eagle represents people in the visa lottery process. It did not sue on behalf of a specific lottery applicant. It sued for the firm itself, claiming harm from the freeze.

The Ninth Circuit rejected that theory. The judges said the firm’s claimed injury was hypothetical and collateral. They also noted the program’s purpose.

The program was intended to "encourage immigration, not generate revenue for law firms."

The panel was careful on one point. It refused to bless the State Department’s delay on the merits.

"We do not endorse the Department’s failure to open the lottery registration period."

The win for the government rested on standing alone. The court did not decide whether the pause itself followed every statute to the letter.

Former federal prosecutor Abhishek Kambli, now a partner at Holtzman Vogel, called the outcome a “very easy call” on X. He wrote that the plaintiff was a law firm acting for itself, not for someone stuck in the lottery line, and that the district court should never have moved past standing.

Chance visas meet a security test the public already understands

Random selection from a hopper is not a security screen. A 2017 lottery winner later carried out a campus slaughter and a professor’s murder. That sequence is why the State Department hit pause, and why a standing ruling now keeps the freeze in place while the administration retools the process.

The Ninth Circuit has blocked Trump immigration measures before, including portions of the 2017 travel order from several majority-Muslim countries and a policy that barred asylum for people who crossed the southern border between ports of entry. This time a majority of the panel refused to let a private firm manufacture a case out of lost business opportunity.

Taxpayers fund the courts, the border agencies, and the cleanup after every preventable attack. A lottery that treats entry like a raffle ticket invites exactly the risk Trump flagged years ago: countries do not put their best names in the drum, and Americans live with the result.

When a law firm cannot force the door back open just to keep its pipeline full, the system still has a pulse.


About Owen Bates

Breaking News:

Check This Out:

Heritage Review is a conservative email-newspaper that publishes every morning. Enter your best email to see our next edition: