A Brooklyn appeals court has cleared the way for Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s tax on high-end second homes in New York City, advancing his push to raise taxes on the wealthy.
Fox News Digital reported Wednesday that a Brooklyn-based state appellate court reversed a September ruling by a Staten Island judge and let the city move ahead with the levy on luxury second homes, also called a pied-à-terre tax.
The earlier Staten Island decision found that the city mishandled the tax rollout and ordered officials to start over. The Mamdani administration appealed that order and kept implementing the tax while the case moved forward.
The appellate reversal marks a legal win for the mayor’s effort to raise taxes on wealthy New Yorkers as the city works to close its budget gap. The tax still faces other legal challenges.
City lawyers did not pause the policy after the Staten Island setback. They appealed and continued to put the second-home tax in place. The Brooklyn appellate panel then wiped out the lower-court order that had told the city to restart the process.
Fox News Digital’s account, drawing on The New York Times, framed the outcome as a victory for Mamdani’s agenda. That agenda centers on higher taxes aimed at affluent residents to help fill budget holes.
No dollar figures, tax rates, or counts of affected homes appeared in the reporting. The precise defects the Staten Island judge cited in the rollout also went undescribed beyond the finding that the city had mishandled it and needed to begin again.
The same administration is defending additional measures, including a proposed rent freeze. Those fights sit alongside the remaining lawsuits against the second-home tax.
New York City residents and property owners now watch a tax that a trial judge tried to halt move forward again after the appellate turnaround. The city kept collecting momentum on the policy even while the September ruling stood as a barrier.
Wednesday’s decision removed that barrier. It did not end the legal risk. Other challenges are still pending, and the administration’s broader tax-and-rent agenda continues to draw opposition in court and in public debate.
When City Hall reaches first for higher taxes on second homes and freezes on rent, working taxpayers are left to wonder how long the bill-payers stay, and who covers the gap when they leave.