Second Amendment group urges Supreme Court to stop Cook County from mooting semi-auto ban fight

 November 12, 2026

The Second Amendment Foundation is pressing the Supreme Court to keep a Cook County semi-auto ban case alive after the county sought to scrap it once a lead plaintiff stepped aside.

Cook County asked the high court on Nov. 5 to drop Viramontes v. Cook County after lead plaintiff Cutberto Viramontes filed paperwork in late October seeking to leave the case. The Daily Caller reported that the Second Amendment Foundation and its partners answered with a response brief arguing the challenge is not moot and should proceed.

The group’s filing centers on a simple point: another plaintiff remains. Christopher Khaya still wants to buy an AR-15-style rifle, including a civilian version of the IMI Galil, an AK-47-style firearm the county’s own ordinance treats as banned.

That sequence matters. The justices agreed on June 30 to hear the case. Oral arguments are set for Dec. 2. A decision is expected in summer 2027. Cook County’s mootness push arrived only after the Court had already taken the dispute.

SAF Executive Director Adam Kraut put the group’s position plainly.

"There’s every reason this case can and should continue,"

Kraut said. He added that the constitutional fight will reach the justices either way.

"We fully expect the Court to agree with our position on Viramontes, but regardless of the Court’s decision, this issue will be heard. SAF has a second case, Grant v. Higgins, that was also granted cert by the Supreme Court so no matter what the Court decides on Viramontes, we will still have the opportunity to present our case to the Justices on Dec. 2."

Remaining plaintiff keeps the Cook County fight live

In its brief, SAF told the Court that Khaya’s purchase plans keep a live controversy on the books. The filing stressed that the Galil is not some side issue outside the question the justices agreed to decide.

"If anything is ‘similar’ to an AR-15, an AK-47style rifle such as the IMI Galil sought by Petitioner Khaya would qualify,"

the brief stated. It went further, tying the county’s own words and ordinance to the remaining claim.

"Indeed, Cook County’s own ordinance groups these rifles together by name and features, classifies them as so-called ‘assault weapons,’ and bans them. The County has not contested any of this until now, and in fact has in its briefing defined the AK-47 as an ‘AR-15 platform weapon[ ].’ It has accordingly waived, or at least forfeited, any argument that the AK-47-based Galil falls outside the question presented."

The Galil ships with standard magazines of 25, 35, or 50 rounds and carries an effective range listed at 600 yards. Khaya indicated he was seeking an AR-15 as well as the civilian Galil. Those details sit inside the same ban framework the county has defended.

The challenge is not new. Viramontes was originally filed in 2021 and targets Cook County’s ban on many commonly owned modern firearms. That local ordinance served as the precursor for a nearly identical statewide ban later passed by the Illinois legislature. SAF has long treated the county rule as a core test of how far blue jurisdictions can go in restricting rifles in common use, a fight that began with the group’s Supreme Court challenge to the Cook County semi-auto gun ban.

Illinois resident Ed Smolen supplied a declaration backing the continued need for relief. He described owning the very type of rifle the ordinance locks out of his home.

"I have owned an AR-15 platform semiautomatic rifle since 2011 but keep it out of state,"

Smolen said. He made the practical cost clear.

"If it were lawful to do so, I would possess my AR-15 at my residence in Cook County for lawful purposes including self-defense."

Connecticut case keeps the Dec. 2 docket locked in

Even if the Court were to side with Cook County on mootness, SAF’s second granted case remains on the calendar. Grant v. Higgins challenges Connecticut’s ban on commonly owned semi-automatic rifles, both by name and by feature set. The Supreme Court consolidated the matters and scheduled arguments together for Dec. 2.

That dual-track posture is why Kraut framed the mootness fight as important but not decisive. One plaintiff exiting does not erase another plaintiff’s concrete plan to buy a banned rifle. And a county ordinance that already groups AR-15 and AK-47-platform guns together cannot easily redraw the battlefield after certiorari.

Gun-rights groups have spent years pushing these disputes past lower courts and into the justices’ hands, including separate SAF efforts such as its bid to block New Jersey’s ban on 3D-printed firearm code. The pattern is steady: local and state restrictions first, then a scramble when a national ruling draws near.

Cook County’s Nov. 5 filing followed Viramontes’s late-October dismissal request within days. SAF answered on the public record, posting that it had explained to the Court why the case should continue and noting the June grant of both Viramontes and Grant. The county’s ban, SAF stressed, was the model for Illinois’s later statewide version.

Blue jurisdictions face a live Second Amendment calendar

The practical stakes for lawful owners are not abstract. Smolen’s declaration shows a resident who already owns an AR-15 platform rifle yet must store it outside Cook County to stay on the right side of local law. Khaya’s declarations show a would-be purchaser blocked from acquiring rifles the county itself has labeled and banned by feature and name.

Those are the people left holding the consequences while officials test whether a last-minute plaintiff change can short-circuit review. Federal courts have already begun pruning other firearm rules that outran the Constitution, including a Biden-era ghost gun rule struck down as unconstitutional. The Supreme Court’s December arguments put the semi-auto bans under the same constitutional light.

SAF’s brief does not ask the justices to invent a new plaintiff. It points to Khaya’s live intent, the county’s own ordinance language, and the county’s prior briefing that treated AK-47-platform guns as AR-15 platform weapons. In SAF’s telling, Cook County waived or forfeited any sudden claim that the Galil sits outside the question presented.

The Court has not, on the available record, ruled yet on the mootness request. What is on the record is the timeline: 2021 filing, June 30 cert grant, late-October plaintiff exit request, Nov. 5 county mootness push, SAF response, and Dec. 2 arguments still on the calendar through the companion Connecticut case.

Second Amendment litigation now runs alongside wider pressure on gun owners and gun-related commerce, from local bans to financial gatekeeping documented when an OCC report found major banks closing accounts over reputation risk. The legal question before the justices remains narrower and sharper: whether Cook County can end a granted case by pointing to one plaintiff’s exit while another plaintiff still seeks a banned rifle.

For now, SAF is telling the Court the answer is no. Khaya’s claim, Smolen’s out-of-state storage of a lawfully owned AR-15, and the consolidated Connecticut challenge all point the same direction. The county ban that helped spawn a statewide copy is still in force. The argument date is still Dec. 2. And the group that brought both cases says the justices should hear the merits rather than accept a late exit ramp.

Local officials who draft broad rifle bans should not get to duck the Supreme Court the moment a live plaintiff makes the case inconvenient.


About Jenny Curran

Breaking News:

Check This Out:

Heritage Review is a conservative email-newspaper that publishes every morning. Enter your best email to see our next edition: