Alabama judge who freed violent offenders denounces bail law as ‘direct assault’ on rights

 November 17, 2026

An Alabama Democratic judge who freed multiple violent offenders now brands the state’s tough bail law a direct assault on constitutional rights, drawing sharp scrutiny over his record.

Circuit Court Judge David Carpenter took to social media to attack Alabama’s Aniah’s Law, the measure that lets courts deny bail to defendants charged with certain violent crimes. He cast the law as a threat to the presumption of innocence even as his own docket history has put him under fire for decisions involving defendants later accused of fresh bloodshed.

The New York Post reported Carpenter’s posts alongside prior bond, plea, and sentencing choices tied to defendants Damien McDaniel, Raukeem Cunningham, and Fredrick Terrenda Hampton, cases that left families and critics demanding answers.

Alabama voters first passed Aniah’s Law in 2022. This year they approved a major constitutional amendment expanding it to cover attempted murder, solicitation or conspiracy to commit murder, and firing a gun or explosives into an occupied dwelling, building, or vehicle.

Carpenter framed that voter-backed approach as government overreach.

Judge equates tough bail rules with license-plate cameras

In a social media post, Carpenter compared public support for denying bail in violent cases to outrage over flock cameras that read license plates on public roads.

He wrote:

“Can someone explain to me why the people who are so alarmed that a flock camera might spot their car on a public road, and they call that government overreach, are silent on the fact that voters across the country keep overwhelmingly passing new laws to empower the government to hold you in jail indefinitely on the basis of a charge only,”

He went further on Aniah’s Law itself.

“These laws, like Alabama’s Aniah’s Law, are a direct assault on the Constitutional guarantee of the presumption of innocence. But no one is talking about this at all, much less expressing the hysteria associated with having a camera see a license plate,”

On Facebook he added another line that captured his view of pretrial detention:

“We are all one accusation away from being a criminal defendant,”

That message lands differently against the cases already tied to his courtroom.

Damien McDaniel’s path after a 2019 arrest

Damien McDaniel was arrested in 2019 for shooting two people in a car. He was 17 at the time.

After his release from jail, he allegedly went on a 14-month shooting spree across Alabama. Reporting tied to that period described 18 people killed and more than 30 others injured.

In April 2023, Carpenter approved a plea deal for McDaniel. The precise terms of that deal were not detailed in the coverage, but the sequence, early release, then a reported trail of shootings, is exactly the pattern Aniah’s Law was written to interrupt.

Bond in a teen’s death, then a Bessemer gas-station case

Raukeem Cunningham’s matter began with the 2022 shooting death of a teenage girl. Carpenter granted him bond.

While out on that bond, Cunningham was arrested and charged with fatally shooting three people at a Bessemer gas station in 2024. Authorities then revoked the original bond.

A judge’s bond decision is not a finding of guilt. It is a judgment about risk. When a defendant free on bond faces new charges of killing three people, the public is entitled to ask what standard guided the release.

Rape charge dropped, then a corpse-abuse plea

Fredrick Terrenda Hampton faced a 2015 rape charge. Carpenter dismissed it in 2019.

Two days after that dismissal, Hampton met Paighton Houston. Houston later disappeared. Her body was found buried behind a home. She had died of an accidental overdose.

Hampton pleaded guilty to abuse of a corpse. Carpenter gave him a 20-year split sentence with only three years to serve in custody.

Critics have described Hampton as a repeat sex offender. Houston’s mother asked Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall to investigate Carpenter over the decision to release him. Whether the attorney general opened a formal probe was not reported.

Campaign talk versus courtroom results

Local outlet 1819 News previously reported that Carpenter had described himself online as a “far left, liberal, progressive, democratic socialist.” That ideological label is his own self-description as relayed in coverage, not a courtroom finding.

During his campaign, Carpenter sold a different pitch to voters worried about crime and costs:

“If elected, I will work to reduce the number of repeat offenders while addressing the expensive problem of prison overcrowding in Alabama,”

Reducing repeat offenders is a concrete goal. The McDaniel, Cunningham, and Hampton sequences are the test of whether that goal shaped his bench work. In each instance, a defendant left his court, by plea, bond, or dismissal, and later faced grave new allegations or entered a guilty plea tied to a young woman’s death and burial.

Aniah’s Law does not erase the presumption of innocence at trial. It addresses a narrower question: whether someone charged with enumerated violent crimes must be released before trial when the charge itself signals elevated danger. Alabama voters answered that question in 2022 and expanded the answer again this year.

Carpenter’s posts treat that voter judgment as silence and hysteria aimed the wrong way. He casts indefinite pretrial detention “on the basis of a charge only” as the real constitutional crisis, while license-plate cameras draw the passion he thinks is misplaced.

Voters drew a brighter line than the judge

The law’s expansion reached attempted murder, murder conspiracy and solicitation, and shooting into occupied places, categories that map onto the kind of street violence described in the McDaniel and Cunningham reporting. Lawmakers and voters built a tool for keeping high-risk defendants held when the charge fits. Carpenter calls that tool an assault on rights.

Families living with the aftermath see a different ledger. A mother whose daughter’s body was buried behind a house asked the state’s top prosecutor to look at the judge who had cleared the man’s earlier rape case. Bond was revoked only after three more people were shot dead at a gas station. A plea deal in 2023 sat against a reported spree that left dozens hurt or killed.

None of those later charges or pleas rewrites the original presumption of innocence. They do measure the cost of release decisions when violence is the charge and the community is the proving ground.

Carpenter wants a debate about cameras and accusations. Alabama already had a debate about bail for violent crime, and put the answer in the law twice.

Judges swear to protect constitutional rights. They also sit where bad releases become funerals, and voters have every right to judge the record beside the rhetoric.


About Jenny Curran

Breaking News:

Check This Out:

Heritage Review is a conservative email-newspaper that publishes every morning. Enter your best email to see our next edition: