Garbarino rebukes FBI Director Patel for skipping worldwide threats hearing

 November 18, 2026

House Homeland Security Chairman Andrew Garbarino blasted FBI Director Kash Patel for skipping the annual worldwide threats hearing, saying the director made clear he had no intention of appearing.

Garbarino, a New York Republican, opened the Wednesday session by calling out the empty seat at the witness table. Deputy Director Christopher Raia sat in for the bureau instead, while Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton showed up as scheduled.

The Hill reported that the committee had given Patel the hearing date back in August and spent months trying to lock in his testimony. Garbarino said that effort went nowhere.

The annual worldwide threats hearing has been a regular fixture for the panel over the last decade. It is built to put the FBI director, the Homeland Security secretary, and the nation’s top intelligence official in the same room to brief Congress on dangers facing the country.

Garbarino says the date was no surprise

Garbarino did not treat the absence as a scheduling mix-up. He said the committee’s outreach was repeated, clear, and early.

In his opening remarks, the chairman laid out the timeline.

"Today’s hearing date was first provided to Director Patel in August. There was no surprise or last-minute request, and despite repeated attempts over the span of several months between then and now to find any date when he could testify, the director made clear that he had no intention of appearing,"

Garbarino said.

He added that the skip broke with long-standing practice for the hearing.

"Director Patel’s refusal to testify marks a significant departure from well-established committee precedent,"

Garbarino said.

Former FBI Director Christopher Wray had testified before the same panel six times for this hearing. Garbarino reminded members that the committee expects the director himself, not a stand-in, when the subject is worldwide threats.

He thanked Raia for appearing, then drew a hard line on who should have been there.

"The committee has been clear in its direct communications to the FBI and through his historical record, that this is a hearing where the FBI director is expected to participate on behalf of the bureau. Our focus on worldwide threats transcends politics, and the director should be here to brief Congress,"

Garbarino said.

FBI says Patel was in the field

An unnamed FBI official pushed back on the idea of a snub. The bureau said it designated Raia weeks earlier and told the committee so.

"The FBI designated Deputy Director Raia for this hearing and notified the committee several weeks ago, and Deputy Director Raia is a career agent with over 20 years’ experience at every level of the Bureau,"

the official said.

The same official said Patel was visiting FBI offices across four different states this week. The bureau framed that as field work, not avoidance.

Raia’s record was the core of the FBI’s defense. A deputy with two decades inside the bureau is not a junior aide. Still, Garbarino’s point was about the office, not the résumé of the person filling the chair.

Thompson piles on with partisan claims

Rep. Bennie Thompson of Mississippi, the top Democrat on the panel and the lawmaker set to take the gavel next year, went further. He cast the no-show as a pattern and a second straight year without Patel at the hearing.

"Director Patel’s absence for a second consecutive year limits the committee’s ability to conduct effective oversight at this hearing. Director Patel is shirking his responsibility to appear before this committee, just as he has shirked his responsibilities leading the nation’s premier federal law enforcement agency,"

Thompson said.

Thompson then listed personal and political attacks that went well beyond the hearing calendar. He claimed Patel found time for a girlfriend’s concert, VIP snorkeling at a Pearl Harbor memorial site, hockey celebrations, and pressure on journalists, yet not for the committee.

"Mr. Chairman, you should take it as an affront that the director finds time to spend taxpayers’ dollars flying to his girlfriend’s concert, go VIP snorkeling at a Pearl Harbor memorial site, celebrate with hockey teams, and intimidate journalists for reporting what he doesn’t like, but has no time to testify before this committee."

Those side claims came only from Thompson’s floor remarks. The reporting did not independently document the concert, the snorkeling trip, the hockey events, or the journalist allegations in the hearing account itself.

Oversight still requires the principal

Mullin and Clayton’s attendance underlined the odd man out. Two of the three expected principals were in the room. The FBI seat was filled by the deputy.

House Homeland Security has a job that does not shrink when the politics get loud. Worldwide threats cover terrorism, border security, cyber attacks, and foreign intelligence work. Members of both parties say they need direct answers from the people who run those portfolios.

Garbarino, a Republican chairman, put that demand on a Republican-appointed FBI director. He did not outsource the criticism. He said the date was set in August, the follow-ups ran for months, and the director still stayed away.

The FBI’s answer is that a seasoned deputy was teed up early and that Patel was on the road with field offices. That is a real operational claim. It does not erase the precedent Garbarino cited or Wray’s six prior appearances for the same hearing.

Congress cannot run serious oversight on press releases and deputies alone when the hearing is built around the director. If the worldwide threats session matters, the person with the title should treat the date like it matters too.


About Owen Bates

Breaking News:

Check This Out:

Heritage Review is a conservative email-newspaper that publishes every morning. Enter your best email to see our next edition: