Conservative attorney John Eastman has petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to reinstate his California law license, arguing the state bar weaponized its disciplinary process to punish constitutionally protected legal advocacy.
Eastman, a former law professor at Chapman University in California and onetime legal representative for Donald Trump, filed the petition on a Friday in September, represented by Jay Sekulow, another former Trump attorney. The filing caps a years-long disciplinary saga that Eastman contends was driven by politics, not professional misconduct. Reuters first reported the petition.
At stake is a straightforward question with enormous implications: Can a state bar strip a lawyer's license for advocating a legal theory that powerful people disagreed with? Eastman says no, and he wants the nation's highest court to draw that line.
In the petition, Eastman argued that California's bar authorities crossed a constitutional boundary when they treated his post-2020-election legal work as grounds for disbarment. His filing put the issue in blunt terms:
"While states may regulate genuine attorney misconduct, they may not use disciplinary authority to punish protected advocacy by relabeling it as professional misconduct."
That sentence captures the core of Eastman's argument. He maintains that what California called ethics violations were, in reality, legal positions advanced on behalf of a client, positions that fell squarely within the protections of the First Amendment. He also contends the proceeding was "politicized" and that other attorneys who participated in similar post-election legal challenges faced no discipline at all.
The selective-enforcement claim is worth pausing on. If Eastman's assertion is accurate, that lawyers who advanced comparable arguments in comparable proceedings walked away untouched, it raises a serious question about whether the California State Bar applied its rules evenly or chose a high-profile target to make a political example.
The disciplinary process moved through multiple layers. In March 2024, a California State Bar Court judge recommended Eastman's disbarment, determining that his efforts to challenge Joe Biden's 2020 election victory were "unlawful and lacked any factual or legal support." The state bar court's appellate division later found that Eastman violated California attorney ethics rules against misleading courts and making false public statements.
Eastman's law license was suspended while he appealed. He argued to the bar court's review department that his rights to free speech and due process had been violated by state bar prosecutors. He also complained that the judge who heard his case singled him out for punishment.
None of those arguments carried the day in California. The California Supreme Court denied his petition for review, leaving disbarment as the final result at the state level. That denial is what pushed the fight to the U.S. Supreme Court, the last venue available to him. The Supreme Court has become an increasingly active arena for challenges to lower-court and state-level decisions touching on elections and political disputes.
The disciplinary case traces back to the weeks following the November 2020 presidential election. Eastman drafted legal memoranda suggesting that then-Vice President Mike Pence could refuse to accept electoral votes from several swing states when Congress convened to certify the vote count. Pence ultimately rejected that theory, saying he did not have the legal authority under the U.S. Constitution to refuse to accept electoral votes.
Eastman also represented Trump in a lawsuit filed at the U.S. Supreme Court that sought to invalidate votes in four states. On January 6, 2021, Eastman repeated many of his election claims at a rally outside the White House. A mob of Trump supporters subsequently stormed the U.S. Capitol and delayed congressional certification of the election.
California's bar authorities treated Eastman's legal work during that period, the memos, the lawsuit, the public statements, as the basis for professional discipline. Eastman's petition to the Supreme Court now asks the justices to decide whether that response amounted to punishing a lawyer for doing his job.
Jay Sekulow, who is representing Eastman before the Supreme Court, did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Questions about how the Court handles election-related disputes continue to surface across multiple fronts, from voter verification access to ballot regulations.
Eastman's strongest card may be his claim that other attorneys who participated in legal proceedings seeking to overturn the 2020 election results were never disciplined. The petition does not name those attorneys, and the details remain thin. But the argument itself cuts to a principle that should concern lawyers across the political spectrum: if bar authorities can punish one lawyer for advancing a legal theory while leaving others who advanced similar theories untouched, the disciplinary system starts to look less like professional regulation and more like political enforcement.
That concern is not hypothetical. Bar associations in blue states have faced growing criticism from conservatives who argue that disciplinary proceedings have been used to target attorneys aligned with Republican causes. Whether or not the Supreme Court agrees to hear Eastman's case, the petition forces the question into public view.
The broader pattern is familiar. Institutions that claim neutrality, courts, bar associations, regulatory agencies, invite suspicion when their enforcement actions fall disproportionately on one side of the political divide. Eastman's case is a test of whether the judiciary will hold those institutions to their own stated standards. The Supreme Court's willingness to weigh in on election-related disputes has grown in recent years, and Eastman is betting the justices will see his case as part of that broader pattern.
Meanwhile, the case also highlights how state-level proceedings can produce consequences that ripple far beyond a single jurisdiction. Eastman built his career in California, taught at Chapman University, and practiced law in the state for years. Disbarment does not just end a license, it ends a professional identity. And when that punishment is imposed for legal advocacy rather than fraud, theft, or client harm, the precedent it sets reaches every attorney who might one day represent an unpopular client or advance an unpopular argument.
Other recent Supreme Court disputes have illustrated how state-level actions can reshape federal legal battles in unexpected ways, sometimes derailing cases before the justices even hear oral argument.
As of the petition's filing, the U.S. Supreme Court had not indicated whether it would take up Eastman's case. The justices receive thousands of petitions each term and agree to hear only a small fraction. But Eastman's case presents a constitutional question, the reach of the First Amendment in attorney disciplinary proceedings, that the Court has not squarely addressed in this context.
Whether the justices see this as a vehicle worth taking remains an open question. So does the broader issue of how the Supreme Court chooses to intervene when lower courts and state bodies produce outcomes that raise constitutional red flags.
If a state bar can strip a lawyer's license for advocating a legal theory the political establishment rejected, the First Amendment means less than every law student was taught to believe, and every American with an unpopular cause should take notice.