Stewart Rhodes breaks with Trump after Jan. 6 sentence commutation

 November 21, 2026

Oath Keepers founder Stewart Rhodes has abandoned President Trump after a sentence commutation, calling him one of America’s worst presidents and alleging widespread pay-for-play corruption.

Stewart Rhodes, the eye-patched founder of the Oath Keepers, has publicly discarded his support for President Donald Trump and now ranks him among the worst presidents in American history.

Just the News reported that Rhodes leveled the attack after receiving a commutation tied to his January 6 case, citing a U.S. war against Iran, the handling of Jeffrey Epstein files, and what he called deep corruption in Washington.

Rhodes did not receive a full pardon. On January 20, 2025, the day Trump began his second term, the president issued mass pardons for people convicted of trespassing at the U.S. Capitol. Several defendants convicted of violent crimes or leadership roles, including Rhodes, saw their sentences commuted instead.

That distinction has not softened Rhodes’s tone. He told the Associated Press the administration he once backed had failed the nationalist populist voters who powered Trump’s 2016 and 2024 primary victories.

"We elected him to end the corruption in Washington, D.C. ‘Drain the swamp.’ Unfortunately, his administration has been one of the most corrupt administrations in U.S. history."

Rhodes went further on the clemency itself.

"The pardons are pay-for-play and everything is pay-for-play."

Eighteen years, then a vacated record

In 2023, U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta sentenced Rhodes to 18 years in prison for seditious conspiracy and other offenses, one of the longest terms handed down in a January 6 case. At the hearing, Mehta described Rhodes as "smart...charismatic and compelling...that’s what makes you dangerous."

Rhodes had founded the Oath Keepers as a militia group that organizes armed protests against government actions it views as authoritarian. The group’s bylaws have denounced racial discrimination and attempts to overthrow the U.S. government. Rhodes is a Yale Law School graduate who earlier worked for former Rep. Ron Paul of Texas.

Trump’s January 20, 2025 actions addressed convictions stemming from the January 6, 2021 breach of the Capitol, where defendants opposed congressional certification of Joe Biden’s 2020 victory. Mass pardons covered many trespassing cases. Leadership and violence convictions were handled more narrowly through commutations.

In August, the Department of Justice moved to vacate Rhodes’s conviction. That step rescinded his criminal record and felon status. The sequence left Rhodes free of the 18-year sentence and later free of the felony label itself.

Trump’s broader use of clemency has covered other high-profile matters, including cases where he pardoned Alaska diesel mechanics onstage while advancing energy projects.

Prison tattoo marked for change

While imprisoned, Rhodes tattooed an image of Trump drawn from the July 18, 2024 assassination attempt in Butler, Pennsylvania. He now says that ink will not stay as it is.

"I will have this prison tattoo of Trump ‘modified,’ to reflect that reality. That treason."

The statement, delivered to the Associated Press by text and interview, frames the break in absolute terms. Rhodes presents the commutation and later vacatur as background, not as reasons for loyalty.

Pardon power remains a recurring tool in Trump’s second term. He has discussed preemptive pardons to shield staff if political investigations target them, and has said he can extend that protection to junior aides facing probes.

Clemency does not erase every grievance

Rhodes’s bill of particulars centers on three claims he has tied to Trump’s record: military action against Iran, the government’s disclosure decisions around Epstein files, and an assertion that corruption still runs the capital. Those are his accusations. They arrive from a man who once organized around resistance to federal overreach and who benefited directly from executive clemency.

The January 6 prosecutions produced long sentences for some organizers and shorter ones for many rank-and-file defendants. Trump’s first-day mass pardons and selective commutations reopened that ledger. Rhodes received the narrower form of relief, then watched the Justice Department move to wipe the conviction.

Similar clemency debates have followed other recipients. In one later case, a man pardoned by Trump faced arrest over alleged threats against federal judges, underscoring that a grant of mercy does not control every later choice a defendant makes.

Rhodes now casts the same president who shortened his sentence as a betrayer of the base. He pairs that charge with a promise to alter the Trump image he carried on his skin through prison.

Trump has also left open the door to further relief for officials, including talk of pardoning White House officials before the term ends and references to prior clemency sprees. The Rhodes episode sits inside that larger pattern of executive grace meeting uneven gratitude.

Voters who wanted even-handed justice after January 6 got a clear use of the pardon and commutation power. They did not purchase a permanent amen chorus from every person released.

Liberty restored is not a loyalty oath, and no serious movement should pretend otherwise.


About Tim Harrison

Breaking News:

Check This Out:

Heritage Review is a conservative email-newspaper that publishes every morning. Enter your best email to see our next edition: